Pefley Cemetery
Russell Township
Section 14
39 49 41N Latitude; 86 55 46W Longitude
This cemetery is on private property. Obtain permission from property owner before visiting this cemetery.
Directions:
The Peffley Cemetery is a little northeast of the end of Co Rd 475W, about ½ mile north of Co Rd 1100N, which ends at 475W.
Condition: Poor
Cemetery is in an old pasture. It is not being mown, but cattle no longer run in the area. The cemetery is pretty much covered with yucca plants that cover the area, not in clumps like you usually see. There are several stones that could be reset, and at least one that is in several pieces. 
The number at the left of each name corresponds with the map of the cemetery.
* = computed birth
Birth Death Age
Surname First Name Other inscriptions M D Y M D Y Y M D
1 PEFLEY   Infant  s/o M. & D. Peffley   May 23 1853 May 23 1853      
2 PEFLEY   David Jr.    * May 24 1792 Aug 20 1869 77 2 27
3 PEFLEY   Mary  w/o David * May 29 1797 Nov 4 1859 62 5 5
4 GRAYBILL Elizabeth    * Nov  26 1773 June 17 1848 72 6 21
5 PEFLEY   Michael  s/o D. &. M.  * June 2 1832 Dec 14 1834 2 6 12
6 PEFLEY   Martha Ella    * Mar 25 1864 Oct 12 1864 0 6 17
7 PEFLEY   George  partial stone, probably s/o D. &. M.         Jan 22 ?? 2 11 20
8 BURKETT Jonathan  s/o W. & E.  * Apr 10 1835 Apr 24 1835 0 0 14
9   Footstone J. B. - probably Jonathan Burkett                      
10   Illegible Stone                      
11   Illegible Stone                      
12   Illegible Stone                      
13   Illegible Stone                      
From previous listings, I couldn't find:
CARTER Sarah  w/o James & d/o David Jr. & Mary Pefley   June 1 1843 Dec 19 1890      
CARTER James Madison     Sept 28 1827 Feb 22 1870