Information on individuals buried in the Mt. Carmel Cemetery
1 ELLIS Matilda Wife of William Ellis. Daughter of Noah and Elizabeth (Gastineau) Lee, who are buried at Stilesville. Matilda's parents were from Pulaski Co., KY.
2 ELLIS William Married Matilda Lee 12 Nov 1867 Putnam Co., Ind. Not sure who his parents were.
3 NICHOLS Maria   Daughter of Randolph and Rebecca Ellis, not sure where they are buried. Maria married Rufus Nichols 3 Sept 1857 in Putnam County. Not sure where Rufus is buried. Since Maria died young, Rufus might have remarried and moved on. Rufus Nichols was the son of Jeremia and Catherine Nichols who are buried at the Fillmore Cemetery.
4 STEERS Ogilva R  Not sure who her parents were. There are two consecutive Steers families in the 1860 and 1870 census records in Marion Twp, Putnam County. Based on the ages of the children and parents, it is probable the parents of this girl were William and Harriet Steers. It is possible the Steers children buried here are grandchildren of Joseph and Sarah Steers who are buried in the northwest corner of this cemetery.
5 STEERS Luella M.  Not sure who her parents were. There are two consecutive Steers families in the 1860 and 1870 census records in Marion Twp, Putnam County. Based on the ages of the children and parents, it is probable the parents of this girl were William and Harriet Steers. It is possible the Steers children buried here are grandchildren of Joseph and Sarah Steers who are buried in the northwest corner of this cemetery.
6 STEERS Maggie M.  Not sure who her parents were. There are two consecutive Steers families in the 1860 and 1870 census records in Marion Twp, Putnam County. Based on the ages of the children and parents, it is probable the parents of this girl were William and Harriet Steers. It is possible the Steers children buried here are grandchildren of Joseph and Sarah Steers who are buried in the northwest corner of this cemetery.
9 KNIGHT Albert Son of James and Sarah (Vaughn) Knight, born in Indiana. From Putnam County Death Records, Book A, page 194.
10 KNIGHT Willie Son of James and Sarah (Vaughn) Knight, not sure where they are buried.
11 KNIGHT John W. Served in the 11th Regiment Indiana Volunteers. Listed among the veterans of the Civil War in the Putnam County Sesquicentennial 1966, pages 47 and 291. Probably son of Lloyd and Catherine (Stanley) Knight, stones 12 and 13.
12 KNIGHT Catharine   Married Loyd Knight 27 Dec 1820 in Wayne County, Indiana. Her maiden name was Catharine Stanley. Not sure who her parents were.
13 KNIGHT Loyd  Son of Thomas and Elizabeth (Williamson) Knight of Maryland. They are believed to be buried at the Oakalla Cemetery in Madison Township. The family is believed to have moved to Fleming Co., KY about 1800, then to Putnam County about 1836. Married Catharine Stanley 27 Dec 1820 in Wayne County, Indiana.
14 ROBINSON John Was on the jury January 1841 for a murder trial. The accused was found guilty and was executed, the first execution in the county. Weiks History of Putnam County, page 227.
15 ROBINSON Sarah Wife of John Robinson, stone 14. Not sure who her parents were or when she and John were married.  
16 ROBINSON Lydia Wife of Benjamin Robinson, who is possibly the brother of John Robinson who is buried here. According to census and other records, Lydia was born about 1804 in Kentucky. In the 1850 census Lydia and Benjamin are living in Marion Twp., Putnam Co. Also in this census were children Joseph, age 20, Caroline, age 14 and Sabra(sp?), age 10. Also listed is Hannah Duncan, age 83. Hannah Duncan is likely Lydia's mother. Not sure where Benjamin Robinson is buried. He is not in the 1860 census which shows Lydia as the head of household along with her son Joseph and his family. Benjamin Robinson's will was probated in Putnam County 11 Jan 1853.
17 CLARK Martha F. Daughter of John and Paulina (Stephenson) Clark, not sure where they are buried. Martha was a sister of Jemima (Clark) Nichols Fortune, first wife of Harvey Nichols who is buried here stone 79. After Harvey died, Jemima married Leonard H. Fortune and they are buried at the Fillmore Cemetery.
18 COOK Joseph T. Not sure who this is. There is a Joseph Cook listed in the Marion Township census in 1860, age 21, which would fit the age of this Joseph Cook. Also listed in this household are Susan, age 44, John, age 20, Samuel, age 16 and Martha J., age 12.
19 DUNCAN Mary Wife of Joseph Duncan who is buried here. Believed to be nee Mary "Polly" Robinson, not sure who her parents were.
20 DUNCAN Joseph Son of Nimrod and Hannah Duncan who are probably buried Shelby Co., KY and Putnam Co., Ind, respectively. Possibly the brother of Lydia Robinson who is buried here. Married Mary "Polly" Robinson about 1819, probably in Kentucky.
21 JAMES Flossie May Probably the daughter of Samuel William and Rosa (Langhorne) James, not sure where they are buried.
22 KING Orie E. Possibly son of Joseph and Lizzie (Frazier) King, who were married in Putnam County 12 Nov 1880. 
23 MONNETT Ulysses A. I don't know who his parents were. The closest match I can find in research is Spencer C. Monnett and Mary Ann Greenlee who married in Putnam County 8 July 1855. 
24 GAMBOLD Narcissa E Daughter of John C. and Anna "Nancy" (Swaim) Gambold. John is buried here, stone 25. Nancy is believed to be buried in Delaware Co., Iowa.
25 GAMBOLD John C. John Christian Gambold. Not sure who his parents were. John married Nancy Swaim 19 Feb 1828. Nancy is believed to be buried in Delaware County Iowa 1856. John is listed in subsequent census records in the Coatesville area in Hendricks County.
26 KNIGHT Walter Son of William L. and Margaret (McNary) Knight, stones 28 and 29.
27 KNIGHT Sadia Daughter of William L. and Margaret (McNary) Knight, stones 28 and 29.
28 KNIGHT Margaret Daughter of J. W. and Sarah (Applegate) McNary.  From Putnam County Death Records, Book B, page 15. The death records listed her as being married, but didn't give her husband's name. Putnam County Marriage Records Book 4, page 56 indicate Margaret married William L. Knight 9 Jan 1867 in Putnam Co., Ind.
29 KNIGHT William L. Married Margaret NcNary 9 Jan 1867 in Putnam Co., Ind.
30 ELMORE Alice Not sure who this is. There was an Alice Arnold that married Alfred Elmore in Putnam County 23 Jan 1876. Also, an Alice Arnold, born about 1859,  was in the household of Comedore P. and Eveline Arnold in Marion Township in the 1860 census. But I could not locate this family in subsequent census records. 
31 ELMORE Walter Son of Alfred and Alice Elmore. His mother is buried here, stone 30. Not sure where his father is buried.
32 McDONALD Joseph W. Son of Clark and Ann R. McDonald who are buried at the Bethel Baptist Church Cemetery southeast of Fillmore. Brother of Shallum C. McDonald who is buried in this cemetery, stone 190. His sister Mary T. McDonald married William Andrew Bunten, who is buried in this cemetery, stone 119.
34 OLIVER Morris H. Son of Morris H. Oliver, Sr. and Catherine Jane "Katie" (Gardner) Oliver who were wed 19 Aug 1852 in Putnam County. They are believed to have died in Putnam County, but not sure where they are buried. Katie was the sister of Luke Gardner, who is believed to buried in the Gardner Cemetery (a small family plot) in Clinton Twp., Putnam Co., Ind. Morris H. Oliver Sr also married Paulina Hessler 12 Oct 1834 in Union Co., Ind. Paulina Hessler might have been the sister of John Hessler, who's daughter Josephine is buried in this cemetery, stone 35.  See also the 1887 History of Putnam County, pages 501 & 509.
35 HESSLER Josephine Daughter of John and Lucinda Hinkle (Henkel) Hessler, not sure where they are buried. Lucinda was the daughter of Simon and Mahala (Myers) Hinkle or Henkel who are buried at the Hartman Cemetery northwest of Bainbridge. Two other children of John and Lucinda are also buried at the Hartman Cemetery.
36 PURSEL Theodore Don't know who this is. I can find no Theodore Purcell, or any other variations of spelling of the surname, in any of the census records.
37 PURSEL Joel Don't know who this is. There are two Benjamin Purcell's listed in the 1840 census, one in Greencastle Township and one in Madison Township. The Benjamin Purcell listed in that census in Madison Township is the only one with a son in the same age range as Joel buried here. I can find no other Purcell's in the 1840 census beginning with the initial B except these two.
38 BRANN Eliza Ann Probably daughter of William and Charity Brann, stone 114.
39 VANDYKE Nelson H. Son of Quinton and Lucinda (Bunten) Van Dyke, not sure where they are buried.
40 WRIGHT Infant d/o A.F.&M.  Infant daughter of Absolom Franklin Wright and Mary "Polly" (Chatham) Wright who are buried at the Clear Creek Cemetery southeast of Groveland.
41 BOWMAN John M. Son of Leonard and Mary M. (Hickman) Bowman, stones 87 and 88. Married Sarah Jane Smith 24 Feb 1864 Putnam County, Indiana. Book 3 page 437. Served as a private in the Company H. of the 11th Indiana Infantry in the Civil War. Listed among the veterans of the Civil War in the Putnam County Sesquicentennial 1966, page 47. Born Shelby Co., KY. 1887 History of Putnam County, page 414.
41 BOWMAN Sarah J. Married John M. Bowman 24 Feb 1864 Putnam County, Indiana. Book 3 page 437. She was the daughter of Robert L. and Elmira Smith, who are buried at the Clear Creek Cemetery southeast of Groveland. Weiks History of Putnam County, page 314. Her brother Johnnie is buried in this cemetery, stone 61.
42 BOWMAN Eartle B. Daughter of John M. and Sarah Jane (Smith) Bowman, stone 41.
43 BOWMAN Mary Etta Daughter of John M. and Sarah Jane (Smith) Bowman, stone 41. Weiks History of Putnam County, page 314. 1887 History of Putnam County, page 414.
44 BOWMAN Claude Orlando Son of John M. and Sarah Jane (Smith) Bowman, stone 41. Weiks History of Putnam County, page 314. 1887 History of Putnam County, page 414.
45 BOWMAN Martha Catharine Daughter of John M. and Sarah Jane (Smith) Bowman, stone 41. Weiks History of Putnam County, page 314. 1887 History of Putnam County, page 414.
46 BOWMAN Lettie Elizabeth Daughter of John M. and Sarah Jane (Smith) Bowman, stone 41. Weiks History of Putnam County, page 314. 1887 History of Putnam County, page 414.
47 STEWART Julina Don't know who this is.
48 ALLEY Rebecca Don't know who this is.
49 OWEN Emrous Probably son of Reuben S. and Sarah E. (Piercy) Owen who were married 27 July 1854 in Putnam County and are listed in the 1870 census in Floyd Township. Possibly twin of Emma, stone 50 which is beside this stone.
50 OWEN Emma A. Probably daughter of Reuben S. and Sarah E. (Piercy) Owen who were married 27 July 1854 in Putnam County and are listed in the 1870 census in Floyd Township. Possibly twin of Emrous, stone 49 which is beside this stone.
51 SIDDONS Louisa Her husband Thomas J. Siddons (Siddens) was an early Fillmore postmaster from Jan 18, 1867 to July 1867. Weiks History of Putnam County, page 172. Not sure where he is buried.
52 BROWN Benjamin C. Served as a Private in Company I of the 11th Indiana Infantry in the Civil War. Listed among the veterans of the Civil War in the Putnam County Sesquicentennial 1966, page 47. 
53 NICHOLS Dillon W. Listed in various records as William Dillon Nichols. Son of Rufus and Maria (Ellis) Nichols. Maria is buried in this cemetery, stone 3. Not sure where Rufus is buried. Dillon W. Nichols married Lucretia Stone 14 Feb 1890 in Pope Co., Illinois. After Dillon died, Lucretia married Charles A. NcNew and it is believed Lucretia is buried in Pope Co. Illinois with her family.
54 ALLEY Hanna Nee Hanna Stevenson, not sure who her parents were. Married Washington Alley 1831 in North Carolina. Washington Alley is listed in the Ringgold County, Iowa 1880 census in the family of his daughter Rebecca Boldon. It is likely Washington Alley is buried in Iowa. 
55 AMERMAN Samuel Not sure who this is. The only Amerman, or variations of the spelling, listed in the 1850 census in Putnam County is a Phillip Ammerman, age 22 born Ohio, in the family of Joseph and Mary Wells.
56 BOWMAN Mariah A. K. Daughter of Leonard and Mary M. (Hickam) Bowman, stones 87 and 88.
  57 BOWMAN William B. Son of Leonard and Mary M. (Hickam) Bowman, stones 87 and 88.
58 BOWMAN Mary M. Daughter of Leonard and Mary M. (Hickam) Bowman, stones 87 and 88.
58 BOWMAN Matilda J. Daughter of Leonard and Mary M. (Hickam) Bowman, sstones 87 and 88.
59 TARBUTTON Margaret Not sure who her parents were. According to census records, Margaret was born in Virginia. The only census records that lists children or grandchildren was the 1840 census which shows Margaret and Eli in Floyd Township with a male born between 1810-1820 and a female born between 1830 and 1835. Eli and Margaret were listed by themselves in the 1850 census in Floyd Township. Margaret is listed in the household of John and Mary J. Adams in the 1870 census in the Mt. Meridian area.
60 TARBUTTON Eli Not sure who his parents were. According to census records and the inscription on his tombstone, he was born in Maryland. Based on their age and the age of their children in the 1840 census, Eli and Margaret were probably married about 1810, location unknown.
61 SMITH Johnnie Son of Robert L. and Elmira Smith, not sure where they are buried. Weiks History of Putnam County, page 314. His sister Sarah J. Bowman is buried in this cemetery, stone 41.
62 BOWMAN Infant Son of John M. and Sarah Jane (Smith) Bowman, stone 41.
63 ALLEN James M. Son of William M. and Mary Ann (Arnold) Allen. The family was in the 1860 and 1870 census in Marion Twp., Putnam County but moved to Kansas after 1870. William and Mary Ann Allen died in Cowley Co., Kansas. Mary Ann's parents James and Nancy (Breckenridge) Arnold are with this Allen family in the 1870 census in Marion Twp., and probably died in Putnam County.
64 ALLEN Catharine V. Daughter of William M. and Mary Ann (Arnold) Allen. The family was in the 1860 and 1870 census in Marion Twp., Putnam County but moved to Kansas after 1870. William and Mary Ann Allen died in Cowley Co., Kansas. Mary Ann's parents James and Nancy (Breckenridge) Arnold are with this Allen family in the 1870 census in Marion Twp., and probably died in Putnam County.
65 ALLEN Nancy F. Daughter of William M. and Mary Ann (Arnold) Allen. The family was in the 1860 and 1870 census in Marion Twp., Putnam County but moved to Kansas after 1870. William and Mary Ann Allen died in Cowley Co., Kansas. Mary Ann's parents James and Nancy (Breckenridge) Arnold are with this Allen family in the 1870 census in Marion Twp., and probably died in Putnam County.
66 RUARK Mary nee Mary Day, not sure who her parents were. Wife of Joseph William Ruark, stone 132.
69 RUARK Andrew J. Andrew Jackson Ruark. Born 30 Aug 1844, died 9 Sept 1921. Son of Thomas and Rachel (Hays) Ruark, stones 134 and 135. 
69 RUARK Sarah E. Sarah Ellen Farmer, daughter of James H. and Emily (Parks) Farmer, who are buried at the Deer Creek Cemetery in Warren Twp., Putnam Co. Weiks History of Putnam County, page 314. She married Andrew Jackson Ruark 22 Nov 1863 in Putnam County. Her husband Andrew was a brother to Joseph Ruark, stone 132, who was the husband of Louisa (Farmer) Ruark, stone 131. Louisa and Sarah Ellen were sisters who married brothers.See also 1887 History of Putnam County, page 519.
70 RUARK Thomas O. Son of Andrew J. and Sarah E. (Farmer) Ruark who are buried here, stone 69.
71 RUARK Ora V. Putnam County Death Records, Book C, page 15 listed his father as "Duck" Ruark. His mother's name was not listed.
72 FOSTER Robert  Son of Harry and Ertle (Ruark) Foster. From Putnam County Birth Records.
73 FRY Lucy M. Daughter of Abner and Sophia Jane (Sweet) Fry who are buried at the Roachdale Cemetery.
74 BRYAN Alexander Son of James & Eleanor (Crawford) Bryan, who are buried in Owen County. James Bryan was a Revolutionary War Veteran. Weiks History of Putnam County, page 645.
75 BRYAN Elizabeth nee Elizabeth Parker. Wife of Alexander Bryan. Not sure who her parents were.
76 BRYAN Nancy First wife of Samuel Harvey Bryan, who was a son of Alexander & Elizabeth (Parker) Bryan, stones 74 & 75, Nancy was born Nancy Case. Not sure who her parents were.
77 BRYAN Frances  Daughter of Samuel Harvey & Miranda Jemima (Kelly) Bryan, not sure where her parents are buried. Miranda was the second wife of Samuel Harvey Bryan, who was a son of Alexander & Elizabeth (Crawford) Bryan, stones 74 & 75. Samuel Harvey Bryan was a brother of Nancy P. (Bryan) Cox, stone 165.
78 BRYAN Ethleen E.  Daughter of Samuel Harvey & Miranda Jemima (Kelly) Bryan, not sure where her parents are buried. Miranda was the second wife of Samuel Harvey Bryan, who was a son of Alexander & Elizabeth (Crawford) Bryan, stones 74 & 75. Samuel Harvey Bryan was a brother of Nancy P. (Bryan) Cox, stone 165.
79 NICHOLAS Harvey Son of Adam and Anna Nichols, stone 113. Note his name is spelled Nicholas on the stone. The History of Putnam County (Wieks), page 541, indicates that Harvey's wife married Leonard H. Fortune in 1879 and they are buried at the Fillmore Cemetery. Harvey is listed among the veterans of the Civil War in the Putnam County Sesquicentennial 1966, page 291. 
80 O'NEAL Ruth Ann Wife of Bailey O'Neal who is buried here. Not sure who her parents were.
81 O'NEAL Nancy J. Daughter of Bailey and Ruth Ann O'Neal who are buried here.
82 O'NEAL Bailey Early settler of Marion Twp., 1826-1828. Weiks History of Putnam County, page 170. Son of Bryant and Lavina O'Neal, not sure where they are buried. May be from Ireland. Three of his children are buried here. Nancy is buried between Bailey and Ruth Ann. William (stone 192) who married Susan Lunsford, daughter of Peter and Sarah Lunsford. Another duaghter Purlina married Matthew Busby and is buried here, stone 103. Bailey O'Neal was a brother of Sarah (O'Neal) Lunsford, wife of Peter Lunsford who are buried in the Lunsford cemetery one mile southeast of Fillmore.
83 BRANN Zarelda Jane Not sure who her parents were. Zarelda and Matthew Brann are listed in the 1850 census in Marion Township with children James, Ruth and Ann, who were born from about 1845 to 1849. In this census, Matthew Brann's birthplace is listed as Ohio and Zarelda's is listed as Kentucky. Matthew and Zarelda were probably married about 1840-1845.
84 ROBERTS Emma F. Not sure who this is. There are at least three Emma Roberts' in the 1900 and 1910 Putnam County census records that could fit the age of this Emma Roberts.
85 BOWMAN Charlie P. Son of Leonard and Mary M. (Hickman) Bowman, stones 87 and 88. Married Sarah Jane Smith 24 Feb 1864 Putnam County, Indiana. Book 3 page 437. Served as a private in the Company H. of the 11th Indiana Infantry in the Civil War. Listed among the veterans of the Civil War in the Putnam County Sesquicentennial 1966, page 47. Born Shelby Co., KY. 1887 History of Putnam County, page 414.
86 BOWMAN George W. Son of Leonard and Mary M. (Hickman) Bowman, stones 87 and 88. Married Sarah Jane Smith 24 Feb 1864 Putnam County, Indiana. Book 3 page 437. Served as a private in the Company H. of the 11th Indiana Infantry in the Civil War. Listed among the veterans of the Civil War in the Putnam County Sesquicentennial 1966, page 47. Born Shelby Co., KY. 1887 History of Putnam County, page 414.
87 BOWMAN Mary M. Wife of Leonard Bowman. Born Mary Magdalene Hickman, daughter of Michael and Catherine (Schumacher) Hickman. Michael Hickman is on stone 146, not sure where her mother is buried.
88 BOWMAN Leonard Born in Putnam County. Married Mary M. Hickman 1835 in Preble Co., Ohio. Not sure who his parents were.
89 BREWER Daniel Early settler of Marion Twp., 1826-1828. Weiks History of Putnam County, page 170.
90 STRAUGHAN N. S.  Nathaniel S. Straughan. Born in Shelby Co., KY, s/o John and Obedience (Scott) Straughan. His paternal ancestors were of German ancestry, and his maternal ancestors of Scotch-English. His grandfather, John Strughan, was a Revolutionary soldier, and his father John was a soldier in the War of 1812. He was married twice, first to Polly Brewer, who is believed to be the d/o Daniel and Nancy Brewer, stone 89, and second to Mary Woods d/o Morris and Charity Woods and widow of Thomas Barnard. 1887 History of Putnam County, page 410.
90 STRAUGHAN Mary Second wife of Nathaniel S. Straughan, stone 90. Daughter of Morris and Charity Woods and widow of Thomas Barnard. 1887 History of Putnam County, page 410.
91 PHILLIPS Charles O. Son of Jacob Winfield Phillips and Mary G. (Straughan) Phillips. His mother is buried here, not sure where his father is buried.
92 PHILLIPS Mary G. Daughter of Nathaniel S. and Polly (Brewer) Straughan. Nathaniel is buried here, stone 90, not sure where Polly is buried. Mary wed Jacob Winfield Phillips 1 Oct 1863 in Putnam County. Jacob remarried after Mary died to Louisa Jane Shields 14 Oct 1866. Not sure where Jacob and Louisa are buried, but the death records indicate Louisa's residence at death in 1911 was Fillmore.
93 DUNLAVY Francis O. Son of John W. Dunlavey, who is listed among the veterans of the Civil War in the Putnam County Sesquicentennial 1966, page 291. His mother was Nancy J. (Straughan) Dunlavey, d/o Nathaniel and Polly (Brewer) Straughan. 1887 History of Putnam County, page 362. His grandfather is buried in this cemetery, stone 90, not sure where his grandmother Polly is buried. Also not sure where his parents are buried.
94 DUNLAVY Sanford Austen Son of John W. Dunlavey, who is listed among the veterans of the Civil War in the Putnam County Sesquicentennial 1966, page 291. His mother was Nancy J. (Straughan) Dunlavey, d/o Nathaniel and Polly (Brewer) Straughan. 1887 History of Putnam County, page 362. His grandfather is buried in this cemetery, stone 90, not sure where his grandmother Polly is buried. Also not sure where his parents are buried.
95 STORM Moses May be the son of Robert G. and Leannah Willis (Christy) Storm who are buried at the Bethel Baptist Church cemetery southeast of Fillmore. Note that this stone appears to indicate the mother is A. W. Storm, but the stone of Pearl Storm, the next stone south, appears to have the mother as L. W. Storm.
96 STORM Pearl May be the daughter of Robert G. and Leannah Willis (Christy) Storm who are buried at the Bethel Baptist Church cemetery southeast of Fillmore. Note that this stone appears to indicate the mother is L. W. Storm, while the mother on the stone of Moses Storm, the next stone north, appears to be A. W. Storm. Not sure if this is an error or what. 
97 CLARK Samuel W. Son of Harvey and Elizabeth (Nichols) Clark who are buried here, stones 99 and 100.
98 TERRY Mary A. Daughter of Harvey and Elizabeth (Nichols) Clark who are buried here, stones 99 and 100. She married Thomas B. Terry 14 Oct 1880 in Putnam County. Thomas Terry married a second time to Ida McNary 15 May 1884 in Putnam County. Thomas and Ida Terry moved to Indianapolis as noted in the 1900 Marion County census.
99 CLARK Elizabeth First wife of Harvey Clark, stone 100. She was the daughter of Adam and Anna Nichols, stone 113.
100 CLARK Harvey Son of Samuel and Cassie (Stephenson) Clark, not sure where they are buried. Harvey was married to Elizabeth Nichols, stone 99, 28 Aug 1856. He later married Levina Ruark, who is on the same stone. Refer to Putnam County Death Records, Book G. Listed among the veterans of the Civil War in the Putnam County Sesquicentennial 1966, pages 47 and 291. 
100 CLARK Levina Daughter of Thomas and Rachel (Hays) Ruark, stones 134 and 135. She was married to Joel Wright 30 March 1851. Not sure when he died or where he is buried. She married Harvey Clark 30 Apr 1867 in Putnam County. 1887 History of Putnam County, page 519.
101 CLARK Paul L. Son of John B. and Marriet "Hattie" (McCoy) Clark who are buried at the Fillmore Cemetery. John B. Clark was the son of Harvey and Elizabeth (Nichols) Clark who are buried here.
102 BUTLER William This stone does not have an age or birth date. There is a William Butler in various census records in Marion Twp, the latest in 1920 where he is a resident of the County Home. Based on the census records, the William Butler that shows up in these census records was born about 1845.
103 BUSBY Purlina Marriage records indicate Paulina O'Neal married Matthew Busby 13 Aug 1854 in Putnam County. This Paulina is the Purlina Busby buried here. Purlina is the daughter of Bailey and Ruth Ann O'Neal who are buried here, stones 80 & 81. Not sure where Matthew Busby is buried or if he remarried after Purlina died.
104 SMITH Elizabeth Daughter of Thomas and Mary "Polly" (Reeves) Newton, not sure where they are buried. Mary is the daughter of Stacy and  Sarah (Lawrence) Reeves who are buried at Brick Chapel. Elizabeth married Abraham B. Smith 1 July 1852 in Putnam County. Not sure where Abraham is buried.
105 HUNTER Isaphena Daughter of Samuel and Isaphena Hunter who are buried here, stones 106 and 107.
106 HUNTER Isaphena First wife of Samuel Hunter, not sure who her parents were or when they married. Note that this is the earliest legible death date in this cemetery at 1835.
107 HUNTER Samuel Settled in Greencastle Township 1822, Purchased Greencastle Lot 120, lying beyond the northeast corner of the courthhouse square for $83.50 about 1822. Weiks History of Putnam County, pages 38 and 107. Samuel was apparently married twice, and his wives are at each side of him.
108 HUNTER Martha D. Second wife of Samuel Hunter. According to Putnam County marriage records her name at marriage at 31 Mar 1836 was listed as Martha Ann Austler.
109 WEATHERLY Isabel G. Not sure who this is. May be mother in law of Charlotte T. Weatherly, stone 110.
110 WEATHERLY Charlotte T. Daughter of Hugh and Margaret (Whitesell) Reat. Hugh Reat was a veteran of the War of 1812 and is buried at the Old Greencastle/Hanna St./Blackstock Cemetery in Greencastle. Charlotte married John L. Weatherly 19 Dec 1850 in Putnam County. Not sure where he is buried.
111 ADAMS Elizabeth A. Daughter of Riley and Elizabeth (Mullinix) Buis who are buried at the Mill Creek Cemetery north of Belle Union. Elizabeth married Eli Samuel Adams 2 Dec 1868 in Putnam County. After Elizabeth died, Eli married Amanda J. Hurst 5 Oct 1871 in Putnam County. Not sure where they are buried.
112 NICHOLS Maggie    Possibly daughter of Anderson and Laura (Tincher) Nichols and grandaughter of Adam Nichols who is buried here, stone 113.
112 NICHOLS Eva Possibly daughter of Anderson and Laura (Tincher) Nichols and grandaughter of Adam Nichols who is buried here, stone 113.
113 NICHOLS Adam The History of Putnam County (Wieks), page 541, indicates that Adam Nichols' wife Anna is also buried in this cemetery. She died at the age of 50, which means she probably died about 1850. Note that Anna is not listed in the 1850 Census in the household of Adam Nichols, but many of their children are.
114 BRANN William Not sure who his parents were. His wife Charity is buried in this cemetery, stone 114. William and Charity are listed in the 1850 census in Marion Township with children Eliza, age 15, Silas, age 14, Martha, age 6 and Charlotte, age 4. This census lists Ohio as William's place of birth. The next home in the 1850 census is that of John Brann, born about 1807 in Virginia. Also in that household is Richard Brann, born about 1790 in Virginia. It is possible that Richard is this William's father.
114 BRANN Charity Wife of William Brann. Not sure who her parents were or when she and William were married. William Brann's tombstone is with a pile of other stones laying at the south edge of the cemetery. William and Charity are listed in the 1850 census in Marion Township with children Eliza, age 15, Silas, age 14, Martha, age 6 and Charlotte, age 4.
116 BUNTEN Sarah A. Daughter of Richard and Mary (McDonald) Bunten  From Putnam County Death Records, Book B, page 14. She was listed as Sadie in the death records.
117 BUNTEN Fred Son of R. W. and M. J. (McDonald) Bunten.  From Putnam County Death Records, Book A, page 196.
118 BUNTEN Addie E. Infant Daughter of William A. and Mary T. (McDonald) Bunten. Her father is buried in this cemetery, stone 119. Not sure where her mother is buried.
119 BUNTEN William A. Son of Andrew Harrison Bunten and Lucy Ann (Evans) Bunten, who are buried in this cemetery. William married Mary T. McDonald 2 Oct 1866 in Putnam County. Since William died young, Mary probably remarried as she is not buried here.    
120 BUNTEN Andrew H. Andrew Harrison Bunten. Son of Andrew and Sarah T. (Burks) Bunten who are buried at the Bunten Cemetery about two miles southeast of Fillmore. Andrew married Lucy Ann Evans 30 Oct 1843 in Putnam County and she is buried here.
120 BUNTEN Lucy A. Daughter of Robert and Margaret (Warinner) Evans who are believed to be buried in Kansas. She married Andrew Harrison Bunten 30 Oct 1843 in Putnam County and he is buried here.
121 LEE Ann E. Daughter of Andrew and Sarah T. (Burks) Bunten who are buried at the Bunten Cemetery about two miles southeast of Fillmore. Ann married James William Lee 10 Oct 1880 in Putnam County. He is believed to have remarried in Indianapolis after Ann died.
122 BRIDGES George W. Son of Moses Thomas Bridges and Mary M. (Vansant) Bridges who are buried at the Fillmore Cemetery.
123 ELLIS Clara I. Daughter of Hercules and Elizabeth (Bridges) Ellis who are buried at the Bainbridge Cemetery. Elizabeth was the daughter of Moses Thomas Bridges and Mary M. (Vansant) Bridges who are buried at the Fillmore Cemetery.
124 BRANN Luna M. Not sure who this is. Marriage records indicate William H. Brann married Sarah E. Fitts 5 Feb 1863 in Putnam County. These are probably Luna's parents, but I can find no other information about them.
125 STORM Isaac C. Son of Hiram Thomas and Sarah E. (Evans) Storm, not sure where they are buried. Hiram was the son of Isaac Jr. and Sarah (Lunsford) Storm who are buried at the Bethel Cemetery.
125 STORM Infant Dau Daughter of Hiram Thomas and Sarah E. (Evans) Storm, not sure where they are buried. Hiram was the son of Isaac Jr. and Sarah (Lunsford) Storm who are buried at the Bethel Cemetery.
126 RAINES Sidney J. Daughter of John B. and Cornelia (Sims) Christy who are buried at the Fillmore Cemetery. Sidney married James W. Raines 21 Sept 1865 in Putnam County, not sure where he is buried. John B. Christy's father and Sidney's grandfather was James M. Christy who is buried here.
127 RAINES Henry W. Son of James W. and Sidney J. (Christy) Raines. His mother is buried here, stone 126. Not sure where his father is buried.
128 CHRISTY James W. The stone of James W. Christy was found under the ground behind that of James Christy, stone 129, when that stone was leveled and reset. It was not listed on any previous listing. We have not been able to determine who he is, but the stone says his father is William Christy and it is believed that James Christy (stone 129) had a son named William. It is likely that this James W. Christy was a grandson of the elder James Christy.
129 CHRISTY James  James Milton Christy, Jr. His parents were James M. Christy, Sr. and Sarah (Scarborough) Christy. James M. Christy, Sr. was born in London, England in 1746 and died 1840 in Monroe Co., Virginia (now West Virginia). Sarah (Scarborough) Christy ws the daughter of Robert and Mary (Bailey) Scarborough, it is believed they are buried in Virginia.
130 CHRISTY Elizabeth Elizabeth (Garten) Christy married James Christy 11 Oct 1804 in Monroe County, Virginia (now West Virginia). She was the daughter of Nathaniel Garten. James and Elizabeth were believed to have had eighteen children. 
131 ALLEN James Born Monroe Co., Virginia (now W. Virginia). Was married to Frances Garten 5 Nov 1810 in Monroe Co., VA. Frances was the daughter of Nathaniel and Mary Garten. Not sure where she is buried. 
132 RUARK Louisa Daughter of James H. and Emily (Parks) Farmer, not sure where they are buried. Weiks History of Putnam County, page 314. Sister of Sarah Ellen (Farmer) Ruark, stone 69. 1887 History of Putnam County, page 519.
132 RUARK Joseph W. Joseph William Ruark was a son of Thomas and Rachel (Hays) Ruark, stones 134 and 135. Joseph married Mary Day, stone 66, 25 Dec 1855 in Putnam County. Refer to the Putnam County Death Records, Book B, page 23.
132 RUARK Mary Wife of Joseph William Ruark. On stone 66 also.
132 RUARK Louisa J. Putnam County Death Records, Book D, page 51 listed her as Louisa Jane Ruark, a widow. Her father was listed as James Farmer and her mother was listed as Emily Parker. 
133 RUARK Marietta Daughter of Thomas Jefferson Ruark and Rebecca (Weatherby) Ruark. Her father is buried at the Fillmore Cemetery, not sure where her mother is buried. Her father Thomas Jefferson Ruark was the son of Thomas and Rachel (Hays) Ruark who are buried here, stones 134 and 135.
134 RUARK Rachel Wife of Thomas Ruark, nee Hays. Not sure who her parents were. 1887 History of Putnam County, page 519.
135 RUARK Thomas Son of Peter and Milkah (Price) Ruark, not sure where they are buried. The family is listed in the 1850 census in Pulaski Co., KY., which noted that Peter was born in Maryland.  Thomas was born in North Carolina. From Putnam County Death Records, Book A, page 180. See also 1887 History of Putnam County, page 519.
136 REEDE Mary Probably the mother of David B. Reede and Jonathan Reede who married Bunten sisters. Several of the Reede children are buried at the Bunten Cemetery southeast of Fillmore.
137 REEDE Olive L. Probably the daughter of Jonathan and Sarah Ann (Bunten) Reede, not sure where they are buried. Jonathan and Sarah Ann also had an infant son who is buried at the Bunten Cemetery southeast of Fillmore.
138 HEAVIN Amanda C. Not sure who this is. This may be nee Amanda Dice, wife of James Heavin who were married 28 Dec 1856 in Putnam County. There is an inscription for an Amanda (Dice) Heavin at the Ragan Cemetery south of New Winchester, wife of James Heavin, with the same dates as this stone. It is possible Amanda is actually buried here, if this is in fact the same person, with the inscription at the Ragan cemetery being in "Memory of" Amanda. 
139 ROBINSON Benjamin F. I can find no information on this individual in the census or marriage records.
141 DRAYER Infant d/o J. & M.  Possibly an infant daughter of Jacob and Margaret Ellen (Randolph) Drayer, not sure where they are buried. They were married in Indianapolis 21 Sept 1862. Margaret Ellen (Randolph) Drayer was the daughter of Presley and Elizabeth (Ruark) Randolph and the sister of William W. Randolph who is buried here, stone 142.This infant daughter Daryer is probably the sister to William Drayer who is buried here, stone 168.
142 RANDOLPH William W. Son of Presley and Elizabeth (Ruark) Randolph, not sure where they are buried. The family is in Morgan County in the 1850 census, then the family is in Marion County in census records after that, without Presley. It can be presumed that Presley died between 1855 and 1860 and that Elizabeth moved the family to Indianapolis at that time. The older children in the family were born in Pulaski Co., Kentucky. Based on their ages and birthplace in the census records, the family probably moved to Indiana about 1840 or 1841.
143 PRATHER James E. Son of Greenbery and Elizabeth (Knight) Prather, stones 177 and 179.  Elizabeth Knight was married to two brothers, Greenberry and Thomas Prather. Thomas Prather's parents were Basil and Cloe (Robertson) Prather.
144 REED Mary E. V. Wife of George Reed. This family is in the 1870 census in Marion Township along with children Margaret, age 5, Robert, age 3, and David, age 1. Also in the household is Ann Shoemaker, age 72. It is possible that Ann Shoemaker is Mary's mother, but I can find no marriage record for George and Mary. It is also possible that George is related to the Reede family buried here and at the Bunten Cemetery southeast of Fillmore.
145 REED  Mary Daughter of George W. and Mary E. V. Reed. Her mother is buried next to her. Not sure where George is buried. Marriage records indicate a George W. Reed married Mary V. Miller 7 July 1884 in Putnam County. Not sure if that George Reed is the father of this Mary Reed.
146 HICKMAN Michael Son of Peter and Regina (Boger) Hickman, who are believed to be buried in Loudon Co., Virginia. Michael married Catharina Shumacher 11 Nov 1813. She is believed to have died in Putnam County after 1862. Not sure where she is buried. She was listed in the 1860 Putnam County census at her son Simon Peter Hickman's home. Michael was the father of Mary M. Bowman, stone 87 and Joseph H. Hickman, stone 147.
147 HICKMAN Joseph H. Joseph Henry Hickman. Son of Peter and Catharine (Shumacher) Hickman, stone 146. He married Mary Martha Gaither 19 June 1850 in Putnam County, not sure where she is buried. 
148 SILL C. E. This is an old stone with an inscription scratched on the backside that looks like C E Sill. There is a Sill family in some of the historical records of Marion Township. On page 291 of the 1966 Putnam County Sesquicentennial is the following: "In June of 1863 there was a fight at the Sill's residence over an attempt to seize and destroy the [Civil War] enrollment records. Mrs. Sill and her daughter hid the records under a board and stood over them while the search was conducted." There is also a James Sill listed on page 171 of the Weiks 1910 History of Putnam County as an early Justice of the Peace of Marion Township. 
150 BUNTEN Edna E. Daughter of William J. and Flora E. (Ruark) Bunten, not sure where they are buried.
151 STEERS Polly Ann Daughter of Joseph and Sarah Steers who are buried here, stones 152 & 154. Polly is also on her parent's stone just south of this one.
152 STEERS Joseph Not sure who his parents were. The family is in the 1840 census in Madison Twp., Putnam County and in the 1850, 1860 and 1870 census in Marion Twp., Putnam County. 
152 STEERS Henry H. Son of Joseph and Sarah Steers who are buried here, stones 152 & 154. The original stone for Henry is just south of this one.
154 STEERS Sarah Wife of Joseph Steers, not sure who her parents were. Joseph and Sarah were probably married about 1820 to 1825. According to census records, Sarah was born in Tennessee.
155 ILLEGIBLE   This is an old field stone that was used as a grave marker. There is an inscription scratched in the stone that is difficult to read. The inscription may be EATD 1842
156 ILLEGIBLE   This is an old field stone that was used as a grave marker. There is an inscription scratched in the stone that is difficult to read. The inscription may be GTD 1842
157 GLAZEBROK Julius From Roster of Soldiers and Patriots of American Rev buried in Indiana Vol 1: "Glazebrook, Julius born 15 Apr 1752 Service Enlisted 10 Jun 1780 and July 1781 at Charlotte Co, Va. Served 5 months under Capt Thomas Williams, and 3 mos under Capt. Andrew Wallace and Cols. Tucker and Holt Richardson, Virginia, Militia. Proof-pension Claim S>F. L6831 died 14 Sept 1847. BURIED Mt Carmel Cemetery, South west of Filmore In. Bronze tablet placed by Washburn chapter D.A.R. mrd Mary, children: James Richard 1787-1847 mrd Catherine Snead." Julius Glazebrook is listed among the veterans of the Revolution in the Putnam County Sesquicentennial 1966, page 43. 
158 SHEPHERD Robert C. Born 1 Dec 1829 and died 4 Nov 1915.  From Putnam County Death Records, Book L, page 57. His wife is listed as Cordilla Frances Shepherd. His parents were listed as Thomas and Susan (Turner) Shepherd. Robert and his parents were all listed as being born in Virginia.
159 RUARK Mary E. May be the wife of James Madison Ruark, who was a son of Thomas and Rachel (Hays) Ruark, stones 134 and 135. If so, she was born Mary Eveline Day, not sure who her parents were. James Madison Ruark is believed to be buried in Russell Twp., Putnam County.
159 RUARK Frank A. Stone is hard to read, it may be Frank R. Son of Mary E. Ruark, who is on the same stone. May be son of James Madison Ruark who was a son of Thomas and Rachel (Hays) Ruark, stones 134 and 135. 
160 BUNTEN Thomas B. Son of George C. and Mary (Shackleford) Bunten who are buried at the Fillmore Cemetery. George C. Bunten's parents were Andrew and Sarah T. (Burks) Bunten who are buried at the Bunten Cemetery about two miles southeast of Fillmore.
161 BUNTEN Infant Daughter Daughter of George C. and Mary (Shackleford) Bunten who are buried at the Fillmore Cemetery. George C. Bunten's parents were Andrew and Sarah T. (Burks) Bunten who are buried at the Bunten Cemetery about two miles southeast of Fillmore. There is only one date on this stone, so it is likely she was born and died on or about the same date.
162 STEERS Sarah C. Not sure if this is the wife of James Steers, stone 163, or his sister. I could find no marriage record for James Steers in Indiana matching a Sarah of about this age.
163 STEERS James Son of Joseph and Sarah Steers who are buried here, stones 152 & 154. 
165 COX Jacob P. Son of Jacob & Frances (Godby) Cox, who are buried in Pulaski Co., KY. Early Justice of Peace in Marion Township. Weiks History of Putnam County, page 171.
165 COX Lucinda S. First wife of Jacob P. Cox, nee Reece. Not sure who her parents were. The original stone for Lucinda is just north of this stone, stone 164.
165 COX Nancy P. Second wife of Jacob P. Cox, they were married 11 July 1854 in Putnam County. Her parents were Alexander and Elizabeth (Parker) Bryan, stones 74 and 75.
167 COX Jefferson W. Son of Jacob P. & Lucinda S. (Reece) Cox, stone 165. He was married twice, first to Emily McCarty 16 Sept 1858 in Putnam County, then to Amanda Barnard 20 Sept 1860, also in Putnam County. Not sure where either of his wives are buried. His fist wife Emily was married to Jacob Shields 19 Oct 1865. 1887 History of Putnam County, page 362.
168 DRAYER William D. Probably the son of Jacob and Margaret Ellen (Randolph) Drayer, not sure where they are buried. They were married in Indianapolis 21 Sept 1862. Margaret Ellen (Randolph) Drayer was the daughter of Presley and Elizabeth (Ruark) Randolph and the sister of William W. Randolph who is buried here, stone 142. William is probably the brother to the infant daughter Drayer who is buried here, stone 141.
170 DENNY Robert B. Son of the Hon. James and Mary Denny, not sure where they are buried. He was married twice, first to Sarah F. Cox, in Nov 1858, and second to Cynthia Wright in May 1862. 1887 History of Putnam County, page 433. Both wives are on the same stone as Robert.
170 DENNY Sarah F. First wife of Robert B. Denny. Nee Sarah F. Cox, probably the daughter of Jacob and Lucinda Cox, stone 165.
170 DENNY Cynthia Second wife of Robert B. Denny. They were married 6 May 1862 in Putnam County. Daughter of Benjamin Wright, Jr. and Mary (Hill) Wright. Mary (Hill) Wright is buried at the Hill/Wright cemetery in Madison Township, as is Cynthia's brother Wellington Wright. Benjamin Wright, Jr moved to Illinois after Mary died.
171 DENNY Infant Dau Daughter of Robert B. and Cynthia (Wright) Denny, stone 170.
172 DENNY Mary E. Daughter of Robert B. and Cynthia (Wright) Denny, stone 170.
173 HARLAN Elmer A. Son of Enoch B. and Sarah (Alley) Harlan, not sure where they are buried. The family is in the 1880 census in Coatesville. Enoch B. Harlan's parents and most of his family are buried in Hendricks County.
174 FITZSIMMONS William M. Son of Meshaek and Susanna (Chadd) Fitzsimmons, stone 175.
175 FITZSIMMONES Meshaek Son of Richard and Sallie (Presson) Fitzsimmons. He and his parents were all born in Kentucky.  From Putnam County Death Records, Book L, page 64. Note the spelling on the tombstone of the name Fitzsimmones.
175 FITZSIMMONES Susanna Born Susanna Chadd, not sure who her parents were. She married Mesaek Fitzsimmons 27 July 1847 in Shelby County, Kentucky.
176 FITZSIMMONS Sallie A. Daughter of Meshaek and Susanna (Chadd) Fitzsimmons, stone 175.
177 PRATHER Greenbery Born in North Carolina. From Putnam County Death Records, Book A, page 18. Son of Thomas and Rachel (Gaither) Prather, both of whom were born in Maryland and are buried at the New Chapel Cem., Watson, Utica Twp., Clark Co., Ind. Thomas Prather's parents were Basil and Cloe (Robertson) Prather. Greenbery Prather was married three times. He was married two times before marrying Elizabeth Knight (stone 179) 6 Oct 1857 in Putnam County. He was an early postmaster of Fillmore, from Sept 13, 1871 to May 1872. Weiks History of Putnam County, page 172.
178 PRATHER Elizabeth Daughter of Thomas and Rachel (Gaither) Prather, and sister of Greenbery Prather. She was apparently never married.
179 PRATHER Elizabeth Wife of Greenbery Prather, stone 177, and also earlier married to William Jennings Prather (stone 189). Her parents were Lloyd and Catherine (Stanley) Knight, stones 12 and 13. Elizabeth was married twice, first to William Jennings Prather 14 July 1842 in Jennings Co., Ind., and later to Greenbery Prather 6 Oct 1857 in Putnam County.  William Jennings Prather was a son of William B. Prather, who was a brother to Thomas Prather, Greenbery Prather's father. Thus she was married to cousins.
180 PRATHER John T.  Son of William Jennings Prather and Elizabeth (Knight) Prather. William Jennings Prather's father was William B. Prather, who was an uncle of Greenbery Prather. William B. Prather's brother Thomas Prather was Greenbery Prather's father. William B. Prather's parents were Basil and Cloe (Robertson) Prather. Basil Prather served in the Revolutionary War under General Gates. Elizabeth (Knight) Prather is stone 179, William Jennings Prather is stone 189.
181 PRATHER Catharine L. Daughter of Greenbery and Elizabeth (Knight) Prather, stones 177 and 179.
182 PRATHER Loyd C. Son of William B. and Elizabeth (Knight) Prather. See narrative of John T. Prather, stone 180 for more information.
183 PRATHER William G. Son of William B. and Elizabeth (Knight) Prather. See narrative of John T. Prather, stone 180 for more information.
184 FITZSIMONS Susan E. Daughter of Meshaek and Susanna (Chadd) Fitzsimmons, stone 175.
185 FITZSIMONS Richard Son of Meshaek and Susanna (Chadd) Fitzsimmons, stone 175.
186 KINSLER Thomas Married three times. First to Patience Chadd 12 Nov 1810 in Bourbon Co., KY. She was the daugther of Samuel Chadd who was a Revolutionary War Veteran. Thomas and Patience had ten children, born in Harrison Co., KY and Putnam Co. Patience died about Apr 1840, not sure where she is buried. Thomas Kinsler married second Rebecca Reeves 4 March 1841 in Putnam Co. Rebecca's father was Samuel Reeves. Her sistee was Beulah (Reeves) Browning, who is buried in the Browning cemetery northeast of Greencastle. This marriage ended in divorce 31 October 1846 in Putnam County. They are believed to have had a daughter Susan, who married Gilbert Sinclair. Thomas Kinsler married third Ellen Clark 14 Jan 1850 in Putnam County. They apparently had no children. Not sure who Ellen Clark's parents were.  Weiks History of Putnam County, page 532.
186 KINSLER Ellen nee Ellen Clark, not sure who her parents were. Third wife of Thomas Kinsler. Ellen might be the sister of John Clark, father of Harvey Clark stone 100. Harvey Clark is listed in the 1870 census in Marion Township, age 36, along with his wife Jemima, age 33 (she is buried here) and there son John, age 6. Also listed in this household is John Clark, age 70, Perline Clark, age 65 and Ellen Kinsler, age 65.
187 BYRUM Mary Not sure who this is. Mary Byrum is listed in the 1850, 1860 and 1870 census records in the Mt. Meridian area as the head of household with (presumably) daughters Martha, born about 1838, and Nancy, born about 1839. The 1880 census lists only Mary and Martha. The only Byrum that would fit in the 1840 census is a Ridley Byrum in Warren Township. Ridley Byrum married Polly Smith 9 Mar 1831 in Putnam County. It might be possible that this Polly is actually the Mary buried here. 
188 COOPER Frances W. Probably daughter of Randolph and Rebecca Ellis, not sure where they are buried. Frances married James R. Cooper 1 Sept 1853 in Putnam County. Not sure where he is buried.
189 PRATHER William   William Jennings Prather. His parents were William B. and Lettice (McCarroll) Prather. Wiliam B. Prather was the son of Basil and Cloe (Robertson) Prather. William B. Prather was a brother of Thomas Prather, Greenbery Prather's father. 
190 McDONALD Shallum Son of Clark and Ann R. McDonald who are buried at the Bethel Baptist Church Cemetery southeast of Fillmore. Brother of Joseph W. McDonald who is buried in this cemetery, stone 32. His sister Mary T. McDonald married William Andrew Bunten, who is buried in this cemetery, stone 119.
191 O'NEAL Flora B. Probably daughter of William and Susan (Lunsford) O'Neal, stones 192 and 193.
192 O'NEAL William Son of Bailey and Ruth Ann O'Neal who are buried here, stones 80 & 82. 
193 O'NEAL Susan Daughter of Peter and Sarah Lunsford, who are buried at the Lunsford cemetery, a small family plot just east of Fillmore. Married William O'Neal probably about 1840.
194 O'NEAL Sarah M. Sarah Margaret (Bunten) O'Neal. Daughter of Andrew and Lucy (Evans) Bunten who are buried in this cemetery, stone 120. Sarah married Marion O'Neal 30 Dec 1869 in Putnam County. Marion O'Neal was the son of William and Susan (Lunsofrd) O'Neal who are buried in this cemetery, stones 192 and 193. Marion and Sarah had several children together. After Sarah died, Marion O'Neal married Martha A. Wright 4 Dec 1877 in Putnam County. 
195 WILSON Sarah F. Not sure who this is. I am not able to fit any Sarah to a Wilson in marriage or census records.
       
The following are in a pile at the south end of the cemetery along the edge of the woods:
A WILSON Sally Bell This may be the daughter of Sarah F. Wilson who is buried here, stone 196. If so, I am not sure who her father John Wilson is. 
A BUNTEN George Son of Andrew Harrison Bunten and Lucy Ann (Evans) Bunten who are buried in this cemetery, stone 120.
A HUNTER Isaphena This person is also listed on stone 106.
A BRANN William This is an old stone at the south end of the cemetery. William is also listed on stone 114.
A BRANN Richard Not sure who this is. There is a Richard Brann listed in the 1850 census in Marion Township in the home of John Brann, age 60 born in Virginia. That may or may not be the same Richard Brann.
A BRANN Charlotte G. Not sure who this is. There is a Richard L. Brann listed in the 1860 census in Marion Township, born about 1810 in Ohio. The other individuals listed in this census are William, age 23 born Ohio, Leroy B., age 20 born Ohio, James, age 17 born Ohio, Mary A., age 14 born Ohio, Isaac, age 12 born Ohio, Abba?, female age 9 born Indiana, Sarah A, age 6 born Indiana and Charlotte, age 3 months born Indiana. This census was taken 12 June 1860, so the child Charlotte was born about March 1860. It is very likely that the Charlotte G. Brann buried here is from this family and died about a month after the child Charlotte was born. 
A BRANN Sarah S. Not sure who this is. It is possible that this is a daughter of Richard Brann and Charlotte G. Brann, who's stone is nearby. This stone is broken and there is no age, so it is difficult to determine when this child was born, but there was a daughter named Sarah listed in the household of Richard L. Brann in the 1860 census mentioned above who was born about 1854 in Indiana.
A BRANN Mary A. Not sure who this is. It is possible that this is a daughter of Richard Brann and Charlotte G. Brann, who's stone is nearby. This stone is broken and there is no age, so it is difficult to determine when this child was born, but there was a daughter named Mary listed in the household of Richard L. Brann in the 1860 census mentioned above who was born about 1846 in Ohio.
A DUNCAN Sarah A. Not sure who this is. There is a Sarah A. Duncan listed in the household of William W. Duncan in the  1860 Marion Township Census, but the age is off by about five years. I can find no record of a Sarah marrying a W. Duncan or a William W. Duncan marrying anyone in Indiana in the age range of this Sarah.
A BOWMAN Lydia This a partial stone with only the date of death and month of age still intact.
A ILLEGIBLE   This a partial stone with only the age still intact. We could not locate the rest of this stone.