Old Bethel/Methodist Cemetery
Warren Township
Section 10 or 11
39 35 02N Latitude; 86 49 54W Longitude
Directions:
Go to the intersection of US 231 and US 40. Go west on US 40 for about mile. At the bottom of a hill, there is a lane or driveway going off to the north between some houses. Go north down this drive about 100 yards to the cemetery. It is a moderate size cemetery, but can just barely be seen from the highway.
Condition: Good
Cemetery is being maintained.
* = computed birth
Birth Death Age
Surname First Name Other inscriptions M D Y M D Y Y M D
BARNES David   * Mar 4 1805 Nov 19 1852 47 8 15
BARNS Rachel A. d/o David & Eliza * Jan 20 1830 Aug 9 1849 19 6 20
BEADLE Albert H. s/o A. C. & S. C. * Sept 24 1866 Mar 4 1867 0 5 8
BOWMAN James L s/o A. C. & S. C. * Oct 6 1858 Mar 23 1859 0 5 17
BOWMAN William E. s/o A. C. & S. C. * Feb 21 1860 Nov 14 1863 3 8 24
BOWMAN Alfred   * Oct 5 1827 Dec 15 1878 51 0 10
BOWMAN Ann w/o John * Dec 20 1791 July 21 1861 69 7 1
BOWMAN Asbury F.     Dec 29 1852 Sept 6 1893      
BOWMAN Bluford G.   * Dec 31 1832 Jan 23 1856 23 0 23
BOWMAN Jefferson   * Apr 13 1828 Jan 4 1851 22 8 22
BOWMAN John   * Nov 17 1784 Nov 6 1852 67 11 20
BOWMAN Julia Ann d/o Alfred & Sarah * Mar 29 1860 Jan 8 1867 6 9 8
BOWMAN Sarah J. w/o Alfred   Mar 5 1835 Jan 6 1918      
BREWINGTON Mathias   * Aug 25 1861 Jan 21 1883 21 4 27
BRIDGES Samuel B. s/o M. & S. * June 13 1881 May 17 1882 0 11 4
BRIDGES Ara A. Peck w/o Thomas J.   Dec 5 1829 Nov 20 1896      
BRIDGES Eddie infant s/o Ara A. & Thomas J. * Dec   1869 Dec 1 1869      
BRIDGES Hercules E. s/o Ara A. & Thomas J.   Feb 8 1859 Feb 8 1860      
BRIDGES Jacob A. s/o Ara A. & Thomas J. * Sept 11 1849 Sept 15 1850 1 0 4
BRIDGES Lucy E. Lewis w/o Henry R.   Dec 5 1830 Apr 27 1876      
BRIDGES Moses W. s/o Ara A. & Thomas J.   Feb 4 1851 May 12 1877      
BRIDGES Sarah E. d/o Ara A. & Thomas J. * June 26 1855 Nov 5 1855 0 4 10
BRIDGES Thomas J. Co. A. 1st Regt Ind Vol Mexican War   May 23 1827 Oct 23 1833      
BRIDGES Catherine   Aug 13 1828 Feb 13 1894 64 6 0
BROOKS David     Sept 26 1825 July 7 1882      
BROOKS Rebecca A. Bruner w/o David   June 15 1825 Aug 2 1885      
CHADD Daniel   * Dec 28 1779 Dec 29 1867 88 0 1
CHADD Liewelmy d/o M. W. & E. * July 31 1872 Sept 15 1873 1 1 15
CHADD Ruth w/o Daniel * Dec 28 1793 Sept 3 1873 79 8 6
CHADD Samuel s/o David & Ruth * Oct 2 1830 Jan 13 1859 28 3 11
CLEARWATER Ezra L. K. Civil War * June 6 1840 Oct 12 1866 26 4 6
CLEARWATER John   * June 28 1806 Aug 14 1845 39 1 17
CLEARWATER Mary E. d/o John & Matilda * Apr 29 1837 Dec 3 1838 1 7 4
CLEARWATER Mary F. d/o T. A. & A. * Dec 1 1858 Oct 25 1864 5 10 24
CLEARWATER Matilda J. w/o John * June 25 1810 Dec 19 1863 53 5 24
CLEARWATER Eliza J. w/o Asel * Apr 4 1826 Oct 21 1864 38 6 17
CLEARWATER Eliza Ann d/o Gilmore & Jane * Nov 5 1833 Mar 9 1876 42 4 4
COLEMAN Elizabeth J. d/o William & Martha Evans * Nov 19 1818 Jan 9 1852 33 1 21
CONNELY Gilmore   * May 5 1799 Apr 27 1863 63 11 22
CONNELY Jane w/o Gilmore * Apr 15 1802 Aug 24 1866 64 4 9
COOPER Archibald Veteran War of 1812 * Jan 15 1798 Apr 17 1872 74 3 2
COOPER Archibald s/o William & Samantha * Mar 5 1853 July 29 1853 0 4 24
COOPER Canada s/o Archibald & Elizabeth * Feb 17 1838 June 23 1838 0 4 6
COOPER Cordelia F. d/o Archibald & Elizabeth * Jan 2 1848 Apr 12 1848 0 3 10
COOPER Elizabeth w/o Archibald   Feb 14 1800 Jan 26 1869      
COOPER Mildred A. d/o I. C. & E. J. * July 11 1858 Dec 18 1866 8 5 17
COOPER Samantha Clearwater w/o William M.   Dec 29 1829 Oct 22 1912      
COOPER William M.     Apr 20 1830 Apr 25 1900      
COWGILL Tarvin W. s/o William & Rhonda * Mar 16 1843 Jan 12 1868 24 9 27
CRAWLEY Charles s/o Richard & Mary   Feb 14 1847 Jan 10 1866      
CRAWLEY Cora P. d/o H. T. & E. J.   Dec 28 1871 Mar 6 1883      
CRAWLEY Elizabeth   * about   1821 Apr 21 1851 30    
CRAWLEY Mary M. w/o Richard W. * Dec 5 1828 July 26 1867 38 7 21
CRAWLEY Richard W.     Feb 19 1821 Sept 19 1891      
CRAWLEY Sarah E.   * about   1843 July 1 1866 23    
CUTBIRTH Homer s/o W. H. & J. * Feb 18 1879 Apr 26 1880 1 2 8
CUTBIRTH Orlando s/o W. H. & J. * Oct 23 1871 Mar 28 1872 0 5 5
DUCKWORTH Barbary E. d/o William & Catherine * Jan 30 1809 June 18 1827 18 4 19
DUCKWORTH Catherine consort of William G. * Mar 22 1782 Dec 1 1830 48 8 9
DUCKWORTH Elizabeth Ann w/o Jonath F. * June 11 1817 Nov 22 1850 33 5 11
DUCKWORTH Katherine w/o William G. * Dec 4 1822 Aug 2 1856 33 7 29
DUCKWORTH William G.   * Mar 22 1783 Dec 1 1830 47 8 9
DUCKWORTH William M. s/o Wm G. & Catheirne * June 28 1786 Oct 27 1866 80 3 23
EVANS George Ellsworth s/o J. W. & M. C. * Sept 28 1825 Sept 26 1834 8 11 29
EVANS James T. s/o William & Martha * May 12 1862 Nov 6 1878 16 5 25
EVANS William B.   * Sept 3 1789 Dec 29 1828 39 3 26
EVANS Marietta E. d/o J. G. & E. * Mar 23 1847 Aug 6 1851 4 4 14
EVANS Mary         1873     1898      
GARNER Barbara w/o F. R. * Aug 24 1833 July 24 1871 37 11 0
GARNER William J. F. s/o S. & N.   Apr 12 1870 July 30 1886      
GARNER Mary E. d/o William O. & Mildred * Jan 3 1836 Mar 14 1852 16 2 11
GOSE Mildred Cooper w/o William O.   June 6 1863 Jan 9 1888      
GOSE William O. Co. E 57th Regt. Ind Vol Civil War   Sept 16 1839 Nov 22 1905      
HANDCOCK Nancy w/o Thomas   Apr 1 1836 May 7 1865      
HANDCOCK Thomas   * Feb 7 1778 Feb 21 1853 75 0 14
HEPLER Calvin         1871     1906      
HILLIS Elizabeth w/o James * June 1 1824 Nov 11 1867 43 5 10
HOWLETTE Infant s/o John & Martha * Jan 20 1838 Jan 21 1868 0 0 7
HOWLETTE John L.     Nov 3 1830 Mar 26 1888      
HOWLETTE Martha A. Connely w/o John "m. 1864"   Feb 6 1831 Aug 22 1868      
HOWLETTE Mary C. Connely w/o John L.   Oct 8 1826 Feb 27 1864      
HUBBARD Elijah R. s/o Jesse & Elizabeth * Apr 24 1851 Oct 11 1852 1 5 17
HUBBARD Elizabeth A. w/o Jessie & d/o J. & M. Peck * Mar 28 1815 Mar 17 1857 41 11 17
HUBBARD George W. s/o Jesse & Elizabeth * Sept 20 1847 Nov 21 1848 1 2 1
HUBBARD Jesse   * Aug 10 1809 Oct 25 1858 49 2 15
HUBBARD Jesse H. s/o Jesse & Elizabeth A. * May 11 1844 July 12 1858 14 2 1
HUNTER Daniel   * May 15 1836 Jan 5 1878 41 7 21
HUNTER Ira N. s/o D. J. * Dec 11 1862 Dec 29 1884 22 0 18
JOHNSON Garrett   * Sept 26 1790 Oct 9 1835 45 0 13
JOHNSON Sarah w/o Garrett * Aug 28 1792 Aug 10 1873 80 11 13
KING Catherine w/o Berry * Jan 19 1808 Feb 9 1852 44 0 21
LANCASTER Jemima w/o William * Aug 6 1829 Jan 18 1851 21 5 12
LANCASTER Isabell d/o William & Jemima * Dec 27 1850 Mar 19 1851 0 2 20
LEWIS Charles Henry Co. I. 127th Regt Ind Vol Civil War "Killed at Cedar Mt" Aug 11 1838 Aug 10 1862      
LEWIS Gabriel Clay Co. I. 127th Regt Ind Vol Civil War   Sept 5 1843 Nov 9 1872      
LEWIS Israel G. "Rev" Veteran War of 1812 * Dec 12 1793 Aug 18 1857 63 8 6
LEWIS Mary E. w/o William Y.   Sept 30 1841 Sept 13 1913      
LEWIS Susan J. w/o Rev. Israel G.   June 8 1803 Feb 25 1890      
LEWIS William Y.     Feb 19 1832 Sept 6 1916      
LONG Elizabeth   * about   1799 Sept 4 1871 72    
MERCER Eli   * Aug 24 1812 Jan 7 1882 69 4 14
MERCER John stone broken         Jan 15 1856 ?? 1 15
MERCER John     Apr 23 1857 Jan 8 1888      
MERCER Lodusky A. d/o Eli & Lucy * May 6 1853 May 16 1878 25 10  
MERCER Lucy w/o Eli * Oct 24 1814 Sept 17 1873 58 10 24
MERCER Melvin A. s/o Eli & Lucy * June 20 1851 Nov 17 1873 22 4 28
MERCER Nancy E. d/o J. & R.         Mar 1 1823      
MERCER Reuben s/o J. & R. * June 11 1818 Aug 26 1839 21 2 15
MERCER Salina U. d/o Eli & Lucy * Mar 20 1849 Mar 14 1867 17 11 22
MERCER Sarah J. d/o J. & R. * Oct 4 1828 Oct 8 1828 0 4 0
MERCER William s/o J. & R. * Dec 13 1821 Dec 20 1821 0 0 7
MERCER William H. s/o Eli & Lucy * Aug 7 1840 Dec 9 1866 26 4 2
PECK Catherine w/o Jacob         Aug 24 186? 69 6 10
PECK Daniel A. s/o B. P. & M. * June 25 1822 Oct 1 1823 1 3 6
PECK Garrett J.   * July 17 1843 Oct 18 1849 6 3 11
PECK Jacob s/o Daniel & Susannah       Mar 28 1857      
PECK Mary A. d/o B. P. & M. * Dec 5 1847 Feb 24 1851 3 2 19
PECK Matilda consort of Jacob * May 9 1790 Dec 1 1836 46 6 22
PECK Priscilla F. d/o B. P. & M. * Sept 4 1845 Dec 21 1847 2 3 17
RECTOR S. stone illegible                    
ROBERTSON Mary Ann w/o G. M. * June 22 1828 Aug 22 1856 28 2 0
ROBERTSON May C. d/o F. M. & Mary Ann * July 5 1856 Sept 19 1856 0 2 14
SHEETS Charles s/o F. S. & E. * Aug 9 1855 June 2 1870 14 9 24
SHEETS Fredrick   * Apr 3 1817 Mar 18 1874 56 11 15
SHEETS Mildred           Dec 18 18??      
SHOWALTER Sarah w/o N. E. * Oct 30 1805 Sept 5 1869 63 10 6
SWIFT Catherine w/o John * Feb 10 1793 Sept 14 1867 74 7 4
SWIFT Flower     May 18 1817 May 30 1895      
SWIFT Infant s/o James & Amanda         Dec 5 1894      
SWIFT John     Mar 11 1789 Jan 4 1875      
SWIFT John A. s/o Flower & Mary A. * Dec 3 1852 May 27 1855 2 5 24
SWIFT Margaret d/o John & Catharine * Sept 10 1826 Nov 10 1829 3 2 0
SWIFT Mary A. w/o Flower   Sept 4 1822 Feb 4 1894      
SWIFT Mary C. d/o Mary A. & Flower * Nov 7 1846 Apr 9 1855 8 5 2
SWIFT Sarah J. w/o Abraham * June 26 1833 Aug 16 1863 30 1 27
TALBOTT Mary F. d/o D. S. & F. A. - stone underground                    
WALTON Lonnie (mortality marker, now gone       1880     1940      
WELKER Eleanor d/o A. W. & S. E. * Feb 7 1849 Nov 9 1852 3 9 2
WELKER Henry W. s/o A. W. & S. E. * Dec 22 1858 Dec 30 1859 1 0 8
WELKER L. L. Rev. "of the Ind. Annual Conf." * June 19 1838 Sept 13 1864 26 2 25
WELKER Matilda K. d/o A. W. & S. E. * Apr 20 1850 Mar 6 1866 15 10 14
WELKER Nancy R.   * Nov 30 1843 Sept 25 1859 15 9 25
WELKER Orlando C. s/o A. W. & S. E. * Mar 7 1853 Sept 9 1854 1 6 2
WELKER Philo s/o A. W. & S. E. Veteran Civil War "died while in service" * Feb 28 1842 Dec 9 1863 21 9 9
WELKER Susan E. w/o A. W. * Feb 17 1817 Dec 18 1875 58 10 1
WELKER Worthington s/o A. W. & S. E. * Oct 3 1824 Sept 29 1849 24 11 26
WOOD Calvin   * June 13 1798 May 27 1873 74 11 14
WOODALL Robert     Apr 15 1803 Sept 10 1877      
WRIGHT Infant s/o Owen T. & K. C.         June 6 1896      
WRIGHT John H.   * Aug 7 1814 Aug 22 1841 27 0 15
WRIGHT Owen T.     Sept 13 1872 Nov 9 1899      
WRIGHT William s/o William T. & A. * Feb 28 1865 Nov 1 1866 1 8 3