Information on individuals buried in the Mt. Pleasant Cemetery
1	Albert Alva Gentry	Son of Alva Homer and Bessie Rosanna (Cook) Gentry. Alva and Bessie are believed to be buried in this cemetery as well, but there is no stone marking their graves. There is a Rector funeral home marker for Alva north of Albert, but none for Bessie. Bessie is likely buried between Albert and Alva. Albert was believed to have been killed by a train.
2	Alva Gentry	Son of James Gentry, who is believed to be buried in Putnam County. He is buried north of his son Albert. There is no stone, but there is a Rector funeral home marker marking this grave. There is another grave between this one and Albert, which is likely Alva's wife Bessie Rosanna (Cook) Gentry, who died 18 May 1952.
5	Robert Reeves	Son of John and Elizabeth (Dicks) Reeves, who are buried in this cemetery. Married Eliza J. Henry 3 Sept 1847 in Putnam County and she is buried here.
5	Eliza J. Reeves	Eliza J. (Henry) Reeves, wife of Robert Reeves. Nee Eliza J. Henry, not sure who her parents were.
6	John R. Reeves	Son of Robert and Eliza J. (Henry) Reeves, who are buried in this cemetery.
7	Mary A Reeves	Daughter of Robert and Eliza J. (Henry) Reeves, who are buried in this cemetery.
9	Ida May Henry	Daughter of Daniel L. and Sarah E. (Reeves) Henry, not sure where they are buried. Sarah was the daughter of John and Elizabeth J. (Dicks) Reeves, who are buried in this cemetery.
10	Infant Daughter Henry	Daughter of Daniel L. and Sarah E. (Reeves) Henry, not sure where they are buried. Sarah was the daughter of John and Elizabeth J. (Dicks) Reeves, who are buried in this cemetery.
12	Frances Reeves	First wife of Stacy E. Reeves. Not sure where he is buried. Stacy Reeves remarried at least once after Frances died, and is believed to have died in Floyd Township. Frances was born Frances Biddle or Bittle, not sure who her parents were.
13	Mary J Reeves	Daughter of John A. Reeves Sr and Elizabeth J. (Dicks) Reeves, who are buried here.
17	John Hulet	May be father of Nancy (Hulet) Dicks, stone 58.
17	William S. Snider	Son of Jacob and Elizabeth Snider, who are buried here.
17	Margaret E. Snider	Margaret married William S. Snider 6 Nov 1851 in Putnam County. Nee Margaret E. Palmer, not sure who parents were.
18	Ira H. Coffman	Son of James W. and Nancy (Arnold) Coffman. James is buried here, not sure where Nancy is buried. Nancy was the daughter of Elijah and Sarah Arnold, not sure where they are buried.
19	James W. Coffman	Son of Parker and Eleanor (Bryan) Coffman, who are probably buried in Missouri. Parker Coffman was the son of Solomon and Nancy (Parker) Coffman, who are buried here.
21	Amanda E. Jones	Daughter of Hiram and Eliza (Reeves) Jones, who are buried in this cemetery.
22	Eliza Jones	First wife of Hiram Jones, who is buried here. Daughter of Stacy R. and Sarah (Dicks) Reeves, who are buried in this cemetery.
24	Stacy R. Reeves	Son of Samuel and Elizabeth (Melton) Reeves, who are believed to be buried in Putnam County. Stacy married Sarah Reason Dicks 22 Oct 1816 in Mason Co., KY.
25	Sarah Reeves	Wife of Stacy R. Reeves. Daughter of George and Elizabeth (Reeves) Dicks. Not sure where they are buried, possibly in Putnam County.
29	Infant Son Hillis	Son of John Lowry Hillis and Indiana (Stoner) Hillis, who are buried at the Forest Hill Cemetery in Greencastle. John Lowry Hillis was the son of Abram and Elizabeth (Peck) Hillis, who are buried in this cemetery. Indiana (Stone) Hillis was the daughter of Peter Stoner Jr. and Polly (Wells) Stoner, not sure where they are buried.
30	Albert L. Hillis	Son of John Lowry Hillis and Indiana (Stoner) Hillis, who are buried at the Forest Hill Cemetery in Greencastle. John Lowry Hillis was the son of Abram and Elizabeth (Peck) Hillis, who are buried in this cemetery. Indiana (Stone) Hillis was the daughter of Peter Stoner Jr. and Polly (Wells) Stoner, not sure where they are buried.
31	Solomon Coffman	Son of Abraham and Ann (Thursby) Coffman. Not sure where they are buried, possibly somewhere in Putnam County. Some researchers feel Abraham and Ann are buried here in Mt. Pleasant Cemetery. Abraham and Ann were believed to have died about 1845. Solomon is the brother of Nicholas Coffman, who is buried here.
33	Drucilla Reeves	Drucilla married James Nelson Reeves 30 Dec 1841 in Putnam County. He is buried in this cemetery. Drucilla was the daughter of Solomon and Nancy (Parker) Coffman who are buried in this cemetery.
33	James N. Reeves	James Nelson Reeves was the son of Stacy Reason Reeves and Sarah Reason (Dicks) Reeves. Not sure where they are buried, possibly in Putnam County. After Drucilla died, James married Arabella, who is buried in this cemetery.
33	Arabella Reeves	Second wife of James Nelson Reeves, who is buried here. Not sure who her parents were.
34	Martha M. Hillis	Daughter of Abram and Elizabeth (Peck) Hillis, who are buried in this cemetery.
37	Abraham Garben	Son of James Edward and Rachel P. (Coffman) Garner, who are buried here. I can find no record of Abraham ever marrying.
38	Harriet I. Garner	Harriet Isabelle Garner, daughter of Solomon and Mary Jane (Johnston) Garner, who are buried here.
40	James Edward Garner	Not sure who his parents are. James is buried beside his wife Rachel P. (Coffman) Garner.
41	Rachel P Garner	Married James Edward Garner 24 Jan 1822 in Monroe County, Indiana and he is buried here. Daughter of Abraham and Ann (Thursby) Coffman. Not sure where they are buried, possibly somewhere in Putnam County. Some researchers feel Abraham and Ann are buried here in Mt. Pleasant Cemetery. Abraham and Ann were believed to have died about 1845. Rachel is the sister of Solomon and Nicholas Coffman, who are buried here.
43	Mary J. Garner	Wife of Solomon Garner, who is buried here. Nee Mary Jane Johnston, not sure who her parents were.
44	Solomon Garner	Son of James Edward and Rachel P. (Coffman) Garner, who are buried here. Solomon married Mary Jane Johnston 20 Nov 1850 in Putnam County.
47	Abram A. Hillis	Abraham Allen Hillis, son of William and Elizabeth Ruth (McCorkle) Hillis, who buried at the Bainbridge Cemetery.
47	Elizabeth Hillis	Married Abram Allen Hillis 25 Mar 1822 in Fleming County Kentucky. Daughter of Daniel and Susanna (Eckert) Peck, who are probably buried in Putnam County.
48	John Mark	Not sure who his parents were.
49	Elizabeth Mark	Wife of John Mark. Nee Elizabeth Detro, not sure who her parents were.
50	Miles M. Mark	Son of John and Elizabeth (Detro) Mark, who are buried here.
51	Nancy Mark	Daughter of John and Elizabeth (Detro) Mark, who are buried here.
52	Abraham S. Coffman	Son of Solomon and Nancy (Parker) Coffman, who are buried in this cemetery.
52	Elizabeth Coffman	Daughter of John Wesley and Elizabeth (Detro) Mark, who are buried in this cemetery. Elizabeth married Abraham S. Coffman 15 Feb 1843 in Putnam County.
53	Ollie Morton Coffman	Son of Abraham S. and Elizabeth (Mark) Coffman, who are buried in this cemetery.
54	Geneva Coffman	Daughter of Melvin P. and Margaret A. (Bailey) Coffman, who are buried in this cemetery.
58	Nancy Dicks	Nancy (Hulet or Howlet) Dicks, wife of Reason Dicks. Not sure who her parents were.
58	Reason Dicks	Son of George and Elizabeth (Reeves) Dicks and brother of Sarah (Dicks) Reeves, stone 25. Married Nancy Hulet 13 Sept 1830 in Mason Co., KY.
59	John S. Dicks	Son of Reason and Nancy (Hulet) Dicks, who are buried in this cemetery.
60	Hiram B. Dicks	Son of Reason and Nancy (Hulet) Dicks, who are buried in this cemetery. Married Anne E. Taylor 27 Nov 1862 in Putnam County. Not sure where she is buried.
61	Addie Hillis	Wife of Reason B. Dicks, who is the son of Reason and Nancy (Hulet) Dicks who are buried in this cemetery. Addie and Reason were married 12 Sept 1871 in Putnam County. Addie is probably the daughter of Abram and Elizabeth (Peck) Hillis, who are buried in this cemetery. After Addied died, Reason B. Dicks married Mary A. Martin 29 Feb 1880 in Putnam County. Not sure where Reason B. Dicks is buried, possibly in Putnam County.
62	Nancy Coffman	Married Solomon Coffman 17 Jan 1817 in Bourbon Co., KY,  who is buried here. Nee Nancy Parker, not sure who her parents were. Her tombstone had been broken across the date of death and due to a poor repair job, the dates are not legible. But the age is clear. Some records indicate she was born Aug 1784 in Maryland and some indicate she died Oct 1874.
64	John M. Coffman	Son of Abraham and Elizabeth (Mark) Coffman, who are buried in this cemetery. I can find no records that would indicate John ever married.
67	Martha Cowgill Dicks Reeves	Martha Elizabeth Cowgill was the daughter of Elisha and Mary Frances (Talbott) Cowgill. Not sure where they are buried. She married Stacy R. Dicks 30 Aug 1870. Stacy and Martha Elizabeth had about ten children. After Stacy died, Martha Elizabeth married John A. Reeves, Jr. 6 Apr 1898. Martha Elizabeth is on the same stone with both of her husbands.
67	John A. Reeves Jr.	Son of John A. Reeves Sr and Elizabeth J. (Dicks) Reeves, who are buried in this cemetery. John was married twice, first to Martha Cowgill (who was in turn first married to Stacy R. Dicks). John A. Reeves, Jr., was married second to Nancy Anna Matkins, who was believed to have died in Kansas about 1892.
67	Stacy R. Dicks	Stacy Reason Dicks. Son of Reason and Nancy (Hulet) Dicks, who are buried in this cemetery. Stacy R. Dicks married Martha Elizabeth Cowgill 30 Aug 1870. Stacy and Martha Elizabeth had about ten children. After Stacy died, Martha Elizabeth married John A. Reeves, Jr. 6 Apr 1898. Martha Elizabeth is on the same stone with both of her husbands.
68	Elisha C. Dicks	Son of Stacy R. and Mary Elizabeth (Cowgill) Dicks, who are buried in this cemetery.
69	Nicholas Coffman	Son of Abraham and Ann (Thursby) Coffman. Not sure where they are buried, possibly somewhere in Putnam County. Some researchers feel Abraham and Ann are buried here in Mt. Pleasant Cemetery. Abraham and Ann were believed to have died about 1845.
69	Levina Coffman	Married Nicholas R. Coffman 25 Dec 1834 in Putnam County, who is buried here. Nee Levina Dicks, not sure who her parents were. It is possible Levina is the sister of Reason Dicks, who is buried in this cemetery.
70	Margaret Dicks	First wife of William H. Dicks, who was the son of Reason and Nancy (Hulet) Dicks, who are buried in this cemetery. Margaret and William were married 28 Feb 1867 in Putnam County. Margaret was the daughter of Nicholas and Levina (Dicks) Coffman, who are buried here. After Margaret died, William H. Dicks married Martha E. Coffman, daughter of Jacob and Malinda (Gorham) Coffman, who are buried at the Old Union Cemetery northwest of Fillmore. The two wives of William H. Dicks, Margaret (buried here) and Martha are cousins. Margaret's father Nicholas and Martha's father Jacob were brothers and their parents were Abraham and Anna (Thursby) Coffman, who are probably buried in Putnam County.
71	Ann McClary Coffman	Nee Anne McClary, not sure who her parents were. Wife of Columbus C. Coffman, not sure where he is buried. Columbus is the son of Nicholas R. and Lavina (Dicks) Coffman who are buried in this cemetery.
76	Nellie C. Browning	Daughter of John S. and Sarah A. (Hill) Browning, who are buried here.
77	John S. Browning Jr.	Son of John Samuel Browning and Beulah Betsy (Reeves) Browning, who are buried at the Browning-Reeves cemetery east of here.
77	Sarah A. Browning	Wife of John S. Browning, Jr. Nee Sarah Ann Hill, not sure who her parents were.
78	William M. Browning	Son of John S. and Sarah A. (Hill) Browning, who are buried here.
79	John A. Browning	Son of John S. and Sarah A. (Hill) Browning, who are buried here.
83	Hiram Jones	Not sure who his parents were. Hiram married twice. First to Eliza Reeves and then to Hannah McCorkle, who are both buried here.
83	Hannah Jones	Second wife of Hiram Jones. Daughter of Matthew S. and Margaret (Patten) McCorkle, who are buried in the Hillis-McCorkle cemetery about two miles northeast of this cemetery.
84	Jacob Snider	Not sure who his parents were. Census records indicate he was born in Tennessee.
84	Elizabeth Snider	Wife of Jacob Snider. Not sure who her parents were. Census records indicate she was born in Tennessee.
85	Smith Parker	There are no dates on his tombstone. Research indicates there is a Smith Parker listed in the 1850 federal census who was 4 years old in the home of Thomas and Lois Parker in Greencastle township a little south of here. If this is the same Smith Parker, that would make his birthdate about 1846. Further research indicates that Smith Parker enlisted in Co B 43rd Ind Inf as a private 10 Sept 1861. Civil War Pension records indicate that Rachel Parker 9 Nov 1914 (dates are hard to read). This application also indicates that Smith Parker filed for a pension as an invalid. Again the dates are difficult to read, may have been 25 May 1895. Marriage records indicate that Smith Parker married Rachel Snider 25 Oct 1866 in Putnam County. Rachel was the daughter of Jacob and Elizabeth Snider, who are buried in this cemetery. Not sure where Rachel is buried. Death records indicate that Smith Parker died in Greencastle Twp 2 Oct 1914 at the age of 69. This would indicate he was born about 1845, which is consistent with the census noted above.
89	Albert H. Coffman	Son of Abraham Coffman Jr. Not sure where he is buried. Albert married Mary Ann Reeves 26 Mar 1840 in Putnam County.
89	Mary Ann Coffman	Wife of Albert H. Coffman. Daugther of Stacy and Sarah (Dicks) Reeves, who are buried in this cemetery.
89	Elvira Coffman	Daughter of Albert H. & Mary Ann (Reeves) Coffman, who are buried here.
89	Hiram L. Coffman	Hiram Luther Coffman. Son of Albert H. & Mary Ann (Reeves) Coffman, who are buried here. Hiram was a Civil War Veteran. Enlisted Aug 1863, Co I, 115th Ind Vol Inf made part of Army of the Cumberland operating in Ky, VA and Tenn. Discharged Feb 1864 in Indianapolis and reenlisted Co E, 21st Ind Inf and assigned Army of the Gulf at Ft William and Baton Rouge. Discharged Oct 1856.
90	James W. Trail	Not sure who his parents were. Married Sarah Isadore Coffman 11 Oct 1893 and she is buried here.
90	Sarah I. Trial	Wife of James W. Trail, who is buried here. Daughter of Albert H. and Mary Ann (Reeves) Coffman, who are buried in this cemetery.
91	Infant Sons Trail	Two infant sons of James W. and Sarah I. (Coffman) Trail, who are buried here.
92	Claud Clay Reeves	Son of Henry Clay Reeves and Louisa Melissa (Cowgill) Reeves. Louisa M. is buried on the same stone as Claud Clay. Henry Clay Reeves is buried in the next row west with a military marker.
92	Louisa M. Reeves	Louisa Melissa (Cowgill) Reeves. Married Henry Clay Reeves 22 Dec 1870 in Putnam County. Henry is buried in this cemetery in the next row west with a military marker. Louisa was the daughter of Elisha and Mary Frances (Talbott) Cowgill. Not sure where they are buried, possibly Putnam County.
94	Martha A. Reeves	Martha Alice (Garner) Reeves. Married James M Reeves 30 Aug 1870 in Putnam County and he is buried here. Not sure who her parents were.
94	James M. Reeves	Son of John and Elizabeth A. (Dicks) Reeves, who are buried in this cemetery.
95	Eliza Reeves	Married John A Reeves Sr. 18 Feb 1828 in Mason Co., KY and he is buried here. Nee Elizabeth J. Dicks, not sure who her parents were.
95	John A Reeves Sr.	Son of Stacy and Sarah (Lawrence) Reeves, who are buried at the Brick Chapel Cemetery northwest of here. Married Elizabeth J. Dicks 18 Feb 1828 in Mason Co., KY and she is buried in this cemetery.
96	Rebecca McCray	Wife of Fleming McCary, not sure where he is buried. Daughter of John A. Reeves Sr. and Elizabeth J. (Dicks) Reeves, who are buried in this cemetery.
96	Fleming McCray	Research 1887 History, and father William
97	Henry C. Reeves	Henry Clay Reeves, son of John and Elizabeth (Dicks) Reeves, who are buried in this cemetery. John is buried with a military marker. His birth date was 20 Jan 1848 and his death date was 22 Sept 1927. Hency Clay Reeves was married three times. First to Louisa Melissa Cowgill 22 Dec 1870, who is buried in this cemetery. He married 2nd Maria L. James 1 Sept 1880 and she is buried in this cemetery also. Henry married 3rd Delila Parrish 5 Apr 1895. Not sure where she is buried.
98	Maria L. Reeves	Second wife of Henry Clay Reeves, who is buried in this cemetery. Nee Maria L. James, not sure who her parents were.
100	Almarinda Coffman	Wife of John Samuel Coffman, who is buried here. Nee Almarinda McDuffie, not sure who her parents were.
100	John S. Coffman	John Samuel Coffman. Son of Nicholas and Levina (Dicks) Coffman, who are buried in this cemetery.
101	Alonzo Waln Coffman	Son of John Samuel and Almarinda (MdDuffie) Coffman, who are buried here.
109	Corporal L. C. McCray	Not sure who his parents were. Possibly the son of Fleming and Rebecca (Reeves) McCray.
112	Maggie M. Turner	26 Feb 1895 in Putnam County. Not sure where Benjamin is buried. It is likely he remarried after Maggie died. Maggie was the daughter of Allen and Mary Jane (Whitlock) Parker, not sure where they are buried. Allen Parker was a brother of Smith Parker, who is buried in this cemetery.
115	Melvin P. Coffman	Son of Abraham and Elizabeth (Mark) Coffman, who are buried in this cemetery. Married Margaret Ann Bailey 19 Dec 1886 in Putnam County.
115	Margaret Ann Coffman	Wife of Melvin P. Coffman. Daughter of Henry and Caroline (Browning) Bailey, who are buried at the Fillmore Cemetery. Margaret's maternal grandparents were John Samuel and Beulah Betsy (Reeves) Browning, who are buried at the Browning Reeves Cemetery north of here.