INFORMATION ON INDIVIDUALS BURIED IN THE WESLEY CHAPEL CEMETERY
LARRY TIPPIN
1 Mary Ellen McCoy Daughter of George and Emerine (Moss) Gorham who are buried at Fillmore.
2 Homer A. Lewis Son of Alexander and Sophia (Pickett) Lewis, stone 4.
4 Alexander Lewis Son of Moses and Sarah (Daniel) Lewis. Sarah is stone 5, not sure where Moses is buried.
4 Sophia Lewis Daughter of David and Elizabeth (Sprague) Pickett, who are buried at the Palestine Cemetery.
5 Sarah Lewis nee Sarah Daniel, not sure who her parents were. Wife of Moses Lewis, not sure where he is buried.
6 Infant son & daughter Lewis Son and daughter of Alexander and Sophia (Pickett) Lewis, stone 4.
7 Joseph Harold Smith Son of Joseph and Sally (Lewis) Smith, stone 172.
12 Thomas N. Daniel Son of Alexander and Emma J. (Randel) Daniel who are buried in this cemetery.
12 Josephine Daniel Daughter of Gazzan and Mary A. (Etchison) Evans who are buried at Groveland. Married Thomas N. Daniel 28 Oct 1875 in Putnam County.
14 Alexander Daniel Son of Cuthbert and Christina (Burk) Daniel. His father is buried here. It is believed his mother is buried in Rowan Co., NC. Alexander married 1st Emma J. Randel 1 Sept 1846 in Putnam County and she is buried in this cemetery, stone 22. Alexander married second Mary A. Higgins 29 Apr 1866 in Hendricks County and she is buried with Alexander
14 Mary A. Daniel Daughter of Thomas and Nancy (Bryant) Higgins who are buried at the Higgins Cemetery in Hendricks County. Second wife of Alexander Daniel.
15 Alilian C. Daniel Daughter of Alexander and Mary Ann (Higgins) Daniel who are buried in this cemetery.
16 Infant Son Daniel Infant son of Thomas N. and Josephine (Evans) Daniel who are buried in this cemetery.
17 James W. Daniel Son of Alexander and Emma J. (Randel) Daniel who are buried in this cemetery.
18 William W. Daniel Son of Alexander and Emma J. (Randel) Daniel who are buried in this cemetery.
19 Catherine Daniel Second wife of Cuthbert Daniel, not sure who her parents were.
20 Cuthbert Daniel Son of Randal and Lucy (Smith) Daniel who are believed to be buried Rowan Co., NC. Cuthbert was married twice, first to Christina Burk probably about 1805 by whom he had about six children. She is believed to have died in Rowan Co., NC before 1822. Sometime between 1822 and 1835 Cuthbert married a woman named Cahterine and she is buried here beside him.
22 Emma J. Daniel First wife of Alexander Daniel. Daughter of William and Nancy (McReynolds) Randel who are buried at the Randel-Ford Cemetery one mile south of Bainbridge.
23 Charles A. Daniel Son of Alexander and Emma J. (Randel) Daniel who are buried in this cemetery.
29 William S. Crouch William Seaton Crouch. Son of Nathan and Sarah (Seaton) Crouch who are buried in this cemetery.
30 Nathan Crouch Not sure who his parents were. Married Sarah Seaton about 1820.
31 Sarah Crouch Nee Sarah Seaton, not sure who her parents were. Married Nathan Crouch about 1820 and he is buried here.
35 Mary J. Proctor Mary Jane (Huffman) Proctor. Daughter of Jacob and Sarah Ellen (Stadler) Huffman who are buried in this cemetery. Married Enoch J. I. Proctor 4 Aug 1880 and he is buried here.
35 Enoch J. I. Proctor Enoch Jeremiah Isiah Proctor. Son of William A. and Mary A. J. (Burch) Proctor, who are buried here. Married Mary J. Huffman 4 Aug 1880 and she is buried here.
36 Arnold Mead Arnold Mead married Ona Proctor probably about 1920. Since there is no death date on this tombstone, so he might be married elsewhere.
36 Ona Proctor Mead Daughter of Enoch and Mary (Huffman) Proctor, who are buried in this cemetery. Wife of Arnold Mead.
37 William A. Proctor Son of Joel Proctor, not sure where he is buried. Joel Proctor was believed to have been born in Maine. He served in War of 1812 and came to Butler Co., Ohio about 1820.
37 Mary A. J. Burch Proctor Daughter of William and Sarah (McNutt) Burch, not sure where they are buried. Married William A. Proctor about 1855.
39 Margaret S. A. Stadler Margaret Susan Ann (Patterson) Stadler. Not sure who her parents were. Married Rev. James F. Stadler about 1870.
39 Rev. James F. Stadler Rev. James Franklin Stadler. Son of Marshall W. and Elizabeth (Ross) Stadler who are buried in this cemetery. 
40 Sarah E. Stadler Huffman Daughter of Marshall W. and Elizabeth (Ross) Stadler who are buried in this cemetery. Married Jacob Huffman about 1855/1860.
40 Jacob Huffman Son of Jacob and Catherine (Sellers) Huffman, not sure where they are buried.
41 Mary A. Fletcher Daughter of Marshall W. and Elizabeth (Ross) Stadler who are buried in this cemetery. Married James R. Fletcher 6 Apr 1866 in Putnam County, not sure where he is buried.
43 Marshall W. Stadler Son of Rev. James F. and Margaret Susan Ann (Patterson) Stadler, who are buried here.
44 Infant Son Fletcher Son of James R. and Mary A. (Stadler) Fletcher. His mother is buried in this cemetery, not sure where his father is buried.
45 Infant Stadler Not sure who this child is. Based on age and location, probably the child of Rev. James F. and Margaret Susan Ann (Patterson) Stadler, who are buried here.
46 Nancy Stadler Daughter of Marshall W. and Elizabeth (Ross) Stadler who are buried here.
47 Elizabeth Stadler Nee Elizabeth Ross, not sure who her parents were. Married Marshall W. Stadler 18 Apr 1830 in Nicholas Co., KY and he is buried here.
48 Marshall W. Stadler Son of John Stadler of Virginia, not sure where he is buried. Married Elizabeth Ross 18 Apr 1830 in Nicholas Co., KY
49 Matilda Shoemaker Nee Matilda Blair, not sure who her parents were. Married Newton Shoemaker 25 Apr 1858 in Putnam County.
49 Newton Shoemaker Son of James and Elizabeth (Wrenn) Shoemaker who are buried in this cemetery.
50 Joseph Otho Waln Son of Joseph F. and Alice (Shoemaker) Waln. His father is buried here, not sure where his mother is buried.
51 Joseph F. Waln Son of James W. and Martha (Allee) Waln, who are believed to be buried in Iowa. Married Alice Shoemaker 21 Nov 1878 in Putnam County. Not sure where she is buried.
52 Julia Waln Daughter of  James and Elizabeth (Howren) Shoemaker. Not sure where they are buried, probably in Putnam County. Married Samuel J. Waln 14 Feb 1867 in Putnam County Marriage Records, book 4 page 69, not sure where he is buried. Samuel is probably a brother to Joseph F. Waln, stone 51.
54 Lovie Alma Timmons Daughter of William and Sarah J. (Waln) Timmons, who are buried here.
55 George S. Waln Son of Henry and Elizabeth (McKee) Waln who are buried here. There is no birth date on this stone, but census records indicate George was born about 1841 in Indiana.
57 Henry Waln Son of Joseph and Mary (Bonard) Waln who probably died in Frederick Co., VA. Henry married Elizabeth McKee 8 Nov 1813 in Frederick Co., VA.  After the birth of their second child they migrated to Ohio where the next seven children were born.  They then moved to Putman County, Indiana about 1830.  The Waln's settled a short distance northwest of Wesley Chapel.
58 Elizabeth Waln Nee Elizabeth McKee, not sure who her parents were. Married Henry Waln 8 Nov 1813 in Frederick Co., VA.
59 Joshua Waln Son of Joseph and Mary (Bonard) Waln who probably died in Frederick Co., VA. 
60 Herman W. Timmons Son of William and Sarah (Waln) Simmons, who are buried here.
60 Mollie M. Timmons Wife of Herman W. Timmons who is buried here. Nee Molly Crane, not sure who her parents were.
61 Elvin C. Timmons Elvin Cornelius Timmons, son of William and Sarah J. (Waln) Timmons who are buried here. Married Rebecca Hansell 25 Aug 1875.
61 Rebecca Timmons Daughter of George and Mary J. (Wilkinson) Hansell, who are buried here. Married Elvin Cornelius Timmons 25 Aug 1875.
62 Sarah J. Timmons Daughter of Samuel and Elizabeth Waln, not sure where they are buried. Married William Timmons 30 Apr 1846.
62 William Timmons Son of David and Margaret (Vandewater) Timmons, not sure where they are buried.
70 Jacob L. Pickett Son of David and Elizabeth (Sprague) Pickett who are buried at the Palestine Cemetery. Married Laura Ann King 20 Feb 1891 in Hendricks County.
70 Laura Ann Pickett Wife of Jacob Lawrence Pickett. Nee Laura Ann King, not sure who her parents were.
74 Sanford Wise Son of Abraham and Sarah Elizabeth (Barnes) Wise, who are believed to have died in Putnam County.
75 Minverva Wise Wife of Sanford Wise. Dau of Barksdale and Martha (Force) Allee, stones 89 and 90.
76 Christina Gowin Daughter of Stephen Merritt & Nancy Logan Gowin, who are buried at Fillmore
83 Martha Wright Wife of Hamilton Wright. Dau of William and Delila Allee, Delila is buried in this cemetery, not sure where William is buried. Grandaughter of Barksdale and Martha (Force) Allee, who are buried in this cemetery.
84 L. H. Allee Lee H. Alley (Allee). Enlisted and discharged sergeant Co. I., 27th Indiana Infantry. Probably son of Barksdale and Martha (Force) Allee, stones 89 and 90 since he is buried near two daughters of Barksdale and Martha. He was not living with his parents in the 1850 census, so he was probably born prior to 1830. Serving in Co. A of the 27th Indiana Infantry were Noah Allee and Marion J. Allee. 
86 W. E. Wise Believed to be William E. Wise, son of Sanford and Minerva (Allee) Wise, stones 74 and 75.
87 John W. Figg Not sure who his parents were. Married Isabel Allee 6 Aug 1883 in Putnam County and she is buried here.
88 Isabel Figg Daughter of William F. and Delila Allee who are buried in this cemetery. Married John W. Figg 6 Aug 1883 in Putnam County and he is buried here.
89 Basdel Allee Often referred to as Barksdale Allee. Not sure who his parents were. He was born about 1792 in North Carolina and was married twice. He married 1st Martha Force 1850 in Guilford Co., NC. Not sure where she is buried, but she apparently died after 1860. They had four children, two of which are buried here and two are buried at Clear Creek. Basil married 2nd Elizabeth Jent, widow of Lemuel Jent 1863 in Putnam County. She is buried with her first family in the Jent Cemetery in Hopwood which is about one mile northwest of the Wildwood Bridge.
90 Mary E. Allee Daughter of William F. and Delila Allee who are buried in this cemetery. 
90 James D. Allee Son of William F. and Delila Allee who are buried in this cemetery. 
91 Benjam A. McVay Son of Edman Reese and Elizabeth (Allee) McVay, who are buried at Clear Creek. Both sets of grandparents are buried in this cemetery. Jacob & Mary (Reese) McVay and Basil & Martha (Force) Ellee.
92 Mary J. McVay Daughter of Edman Reese and Elizabeth (Allee) McVay, who are buried at Clear Creek. Both sets of grandparents are buried in this cemetery. Jacob & Mary (Reese) McVay and Basil & Martha (Force) Ellee. This stone is broken across the death date. According to census records Mary was born about 1847. The stone says she was 17y 9m 9d at death, so the death date was probably about 1864.
93 Mary McVay Nee Mary Reese, not sure who her parents were. Born in Tennessee. Married Jacob McVay 14 Sept 1814, probably in Tennessee.
93 Jacob McVay Not sure who his parents were. Born in Pennsylvania. Came to Floyd Twp., Putnam County 1830-1833 per History of Putnam County, page 218. Served in War of 1812 according to page 386 of the 1887 History of Putnam County.
94 Sarah M. McVay Daughter of Jacob and Mary (Reese) McVay who are buried in this cemetery.
95 William F. Alley Son of Basil and Martha (Force) Allee. His father is buried here, but not sure where his mother is buried. Tombstone is broken. Death date is 16 June 18__. He was in the 1870 census, but not the 1880, so he probably died in the 1870's.
96 Delilah Alley Not sure who her parents Were. She married William F. Allee about 1874.
97 Hepsiby R. Todd Daughter of William F. and Delilah Alley (or Allee), who are buried here. Married William R. Todd 13 Nov 1873 in Putnam County.
97 William R. Todd Son of David and Delilah (Nichols) Todd who are buried at Clear Creek.
102 Edna K. Shoemaker nee Edna K. Dicks, Putnam County Marriage Records, Book 14 page 382, 26 Dec 1912.
119 Louetta Shoemaker Daughter of Wicklife and Rachel (Hansel) Mason, who are buried in this cemetery. Married Jacob Henry Shoemaker 17 Feb 1892 in Putnam County.
119 J. H. Shoemaker Jacob Henry Shoemaker. Son of Daniel E. and Louisa (Stobaugh) Shoemaker who are buried here. Married Louetta Mason 17 Feb 1892 in Putnam County.
121 James Shoemaker Son of Evan and Eve (Elliot) Shoemaker. Evan Shoemaker is believed to be buried in Randoph County, Indiana. Eve died 1865, probably in Putnam County. Not sure where she is buried.
121 Elizabeth Shoemaker Nee Elizabeth Howren, not sure who her parents were. Married James Shoemaker 4 Sept 1834 in Union Co., Ind.
124 Unknown Baldon Stone is broken at the top, but is probably Elizabeth Baldon who was the daughter of Jacob and Ursula (Emmons) Stobaugh, who are believed to be buried at the old home place about one mile west of the Leroy Zeiner farm north of Fillmore.
125 Joseph Stobaugh Son of Jacob and Ursula (Emmons) Stobaugh, who are believed to be buried at the old home place about one mile west of the Leroy Zeiner farm north of Fillmore.
126 Louisa Shoemaker Daughter of  Jacob and Ursula (Emmons) Stobaugh, who are believed to be buried at the old home place about one mile west of the Leroy Zeiner farm north of Fillmore. Married Daniel E. Shoemaker 10 Oct 1860 in Putnam County.
126 D. E. Shoemaker Daniel E. Shoemaker. Son of James and Elizabeth (Howren) Shoemaker, who are buried here. Married Louisa Stobaugh 10 Oct 1860 in Putnam County.
133 Ollie A. Wright Hansell Daughter of Absolom M. and Amanda (Chatham) Wright, not sure where they are buried. Married Jonathan Hansell 3 Aug 1887. Jonathan is buried in this cemetery with his second wife Clora A. (Wise) Hansell.
134 Wickliff Mason Son of Anslem and Alice Ann (Shouse) Mason, not sure where they are buried. He was married twice. First on 29 Jan 1856 to Nancy Elizabeth Shinn, who is buried at the Palestine Cemetery. Nancy was the daughter of Samuel and Mary Ann (Waln) Shinn. Wickliff married second Rachel Marie Hansell 27 Nov 1863.
134 Rachel Mason Second wife of Wickliff Mason, who is buried here. Daughter of George and Mary A. (Wilkinson) Hansell, who are buried here.
135 Mary Ann Hansell Daughter of Elijah C, and Elizabeth Wilkinson who are buried in this cemetery. 
135 George Hansell Son of John and Hannah (Adams) Hansell, not sure where they are buried. George was believed to have been born in Frederick Co., VA. He married Mary A. Wilkinson probably about 1835.
136 Betsey Ann Wilkinson Not sure who her parents Were. She married John Wilkinson and he is buried in this cemetery.
137 Lydia Wilkinson Daughter of William and Zerelda (Moss) Purcell who are buried at the Old Union Cemetery northwest of Fillmore. Married Elijah Wilkinson and he is buried here.
139 George W. Flint George Washington Flint, not sure who his parents were. He was believed to have been born in Troopersville, Vayuga Co., N.Y. George married Sarah Ann Lane 22 Oct 1857 in Putnam County and she is buried here.
139 Sarah A. Flint Wife of George W. Flint who is buried here. Daughter of Sanford and Sophia (Stadler) Lane, who are believed to be buried somewhere nearby.
140 Robert W. Lane Son of Sanford and Sophia (Stadler) Lane, who are believed to be buried somewhere nearby. Robert Lane died while serving in the Civil War.
141 Harry Lane Son of Sanford and Sophia (Stadler) Lane, who are believed to be buried somewhere nearby.
142 Infant Daughter Lane Daughter of Sanford and Sophia (Stadler) Lane, who are believed to be buried somewhere nearby.
143 Infant Son Flint Son of George W. and Sarah Ann (Lane) Flint who are buried here.
144 Milton S. Flint Son of George W. and Sarah Ann (Lane) Flint who are buried here.
145 John W. Flint Son of George W. and Sarah Ann (Lane) Flint who are buried here.
147 Jonathan Hansel Son of George and Mary A. (Wilkinson) Hansell who are buried here. Twin of Jehu Hansell, not sure where he is buried. Jonathan married 1st Ollie A. Wright 3 Aug 1887 and 2nd Clora A. Wise 20 Mar 1902. Both wives are buried in this cemetery.
147 Clora A. Hansel Daughter of Isaac and Regina (Newman) Wise, not sure where they are buried. Second wife of Jonathan Hansell, who is buried here.
148 Martha Waln Daughter of Elijah C, and Elizabeth Wilkinson who are buried in this cemetery.  Married John Waln about 1830/1835.
148 John Waln Son of John and Elizabath (McKee) Waln who are buried here. Married Martha Wilkinson about 1830/1835 and she is buried here.
149 Rececca Davis Waln Second wife of Elijah Cooper Waln, stone 150. Nee Rebecca J. Davis, not sure who her parents were.
150 Elijah C. Waln Elijah Cooper Waln. Son of John and Martha (Wilkinson) Waln who are buried here. Elijah married 1st Mary R. Coffman 8 Jan 1862 in Putnam County and 2nd Rebecca Davis 28 Apr 1898. Both wives are buried at each side of Elijah.
151 Mary R. Waln First  wife of Elijah Waln, stone 150. Daughter of Nicholas and Levina (Dicks) Coffman, who are buried at the Mt. Pleasant Cemetery.
152 Gracie Waln Daughter of Elijah Cooper Waln and Mary R. (Coffman) Waln who are buried here.
153 Bessie Waln Daughter of Elijah Cooper Waln and Mary R. (Coffman) Waln who are buried here.
154 Leonard J. Waln Son of Elijah Cooper Waln and Mary R. (Coffman) Waln who are buried here.
155 John N. Waln Son of Elijah Cooper Waln and Mary R. (Coffman) Waln who are buried here.
156 Mary Waln Daughter of Elijah Cooper Waln and Mary R. (Coffman) Waln who are buried here.
157 Olive E. Waln Daughter of Elijah Cooper Waln and Mary R. (Coffman) Waln who are buried here.
159 Elijah C. Wilkinson Not sure who his parents were. 
159 Elizabeth Wilkinson Not sure who her parents were. Married Elijan C. Wilkinson probably about 1812.
161 Samuel E. Waln Son of Elijah Cooper Waln and Mary R. (Coffman) Waln who are buried here.
162 John Wilkinson Son of Elijah C. and Elizabeth Wilkinson who are buried in this cemetery. John actually has two stones. This one an another leaning against the northeast corner fence, stone number 176.
163 Joseph Hansell Son of George and Mary A. (Wilkinson) Hansell who are buried here.
164 Infant Daughter Mason Daughter of Wicklife and Rachel (Hansel) Mason, who are buried in this cemetery.
164 Infant Daughter Mason Daughter of Wicklife and Rachel (Hansel) Mason, who are buried in this cemetery.
169 Elijah W. Flint Son of George and Sarah (Lane) Flint who are buried in this cemetery. Married Mary A. Carroll 16 Jan 1898 in Putnam County and she is buried here.
169 Mary A. Flint Wife of Elijah W. Flint who is buried here. Nee Mary Ann Carroll, not sure who her parents were.
172 Sallie E. Smith Daughter of Alexander and Sophia (Pickett) Lewis who are buried in this cemetery.
172 Joseph A. Smith Son of Alexander and Ann Mary (Wilson) Smith who are buried at Clear Creek. Joseph married Sallie E. Lewis about 1920.
176 John Wilkinson See stone 162.
Elijah N. Wilkinson Elijah N. Wilkinson, son of Elijah C. and Elizabeth Wilkinson who are buried in this cemetery is supposed to be buried in this cemetery as well. But I have yet to locate his stone.